Why was "the Tree" placed in the center of the garden (orchard)

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

face2face

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2015
8,243
1,202
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
2 Peter 2:4-6
Angels who sinned (2 Peter 2:4):
This likely refers to the fallen angels from Genesis 6:1-4 (the "sons of God" who came to the daughters of men) and possibly references extra-biblical Jewish tradition (like the Book of Enoch), where the sin of these angels is elaborated on.

Noah and the flood (2 Peter 2:5):
A clear reference to Genesis 6-8, where God brought judgment upon the ancient world but preserved Noah, a preacher of righteousness, and his family.
OT story

Sodom and Gomorrah (2 Peter 2:6):
Refers to Genesis 19 where God destroyed these cities due to their wickedness, particularly their extreme immorality. The destruction by fire serves as an example of God's judgment.
OT Story
2 Peter 2:15-16
Balaam (2 Peter 2:15-16):
This is a reference to the story of Balaam, found in Numbers 22-24. Balaam, a prophet, was hired by Balak, king of Moab, to curse Israel, but God intervened through Balaam's donkey, and Balaam was rebuked for his greed and desire to profit from unrighteousness.
OT story
Jude 1:5-7
Israel's unbelief after the Exodus (Jude 1:5):
Refers to Numbers 14 when the Israelites rebelled against God and refused to enter the Promised Land, leading to their wandering in the wilderness.

Angels who did not keep their positions of authority (Jude 1:6):
Similar to 2 Peter, this is likely referencing the fallen angels from Genesis 6:1-4 or Jewish traditions about their rebellion.
OT story - Korah Dathan and Abiram
Sodom and Gomorrah (Jude 1:7):
Again, a reference to Genesis 19, where these cities were judged for their sexual immorality and corruption.
Jude 1:11
OT Story
Cain:
Refers to Genesis 4:1-16, where Cain, the firstborn of Adam and Eve, killed his brother Abel out of jealousy, becoming the first murderer.
Balaam:
As in 2 Peter, this refers to Numbers 22-24, where Balaam's greed led him astray.
OT Story
Korah's rebellion:
Refers to Numbers 16, where Korah led a rebellion against Moses and Aaron, questioning their authority, and God judged Korah and his followers by having the earth swallow them up.
OT Story
What can I glean from this?

Fallen Angels (Genesis 6:1-4)
No Origin Story - Sorry J....nice try though ;)
Noah and the Flood (Genesis 6-8)
Correct
Sodom and Gomorrah (Genesis 19)
Correct
Balaam (Numbers 22-24)

Cain (Genesis 4:1-16)

Israel's Unbelief in the Wilderness (Numbers 14)

Korah's Rebellion (Numbers 16)

Shalom.
J.
So you have 95% pass mark J.

Well done

Happy to mark this once you get Genesis 6 right

F2F
 
Last edited:
J

Johann

Guest
We have been down this rabbit hole before J. many times
Brother, we may have had our disagreements in the past, but right now, we’re focusing on discussing Scripture-not personal opinions, not F2F or Johann. Whether you believe it or not, I’ve mellowed out quite a bit since then.
J.
 
  • Like
Reactions: face2face

face2face

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2015
8,243
1,202
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Brother, we may have had our disagreements in the past, but right now, we’re focusing on discussing Scripture-not personal opinions, not F2F or Johann. Whether you believe it or not, I’ve mellowed out quite a bit since then.
J.
What do you want to discuss?
Forbidden topics?
F2F
 
  • Like
Reactions: Johann

face2face

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2015
8,243
1,202
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Elaborate @face2face.
Thanks
J.
Because there is no origin story for all the colourful notions people use of angels falling, they are at a loss for proving angels can sin. It's a ridiculous subject J. because the Word of God presents them as not being able to sin, or die.

Forcing mythology onto the text is typical of believers who love to have their ears tickled, if you get my drift.

F2F
 
J

Johann

Guest
Because there is no origin story for all the colourful notions people use of angels falling, they are at a loss for proving angels can sin. It's a ridiculous subject J. because the Word of God presents them as not being able to sin, or die.

Forcing mythology onto the text is typical of believers who love to have their ears tickled, if you get my drift
OK-won't force the point.
J.
 

face2face

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2015
8,243
1,202
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
OK-won't force the point.
J.
This subject goes to the centre of God's Holiness and How His Ministering Spirits are His Spirit (behold His Face).

He cannot be double-minded, impossible.

Any text which is misrepresented as such, needs very close attention.

F2F
 
  • Like
Reactions: Johann
J

Johann

Guest
Because there is no origin story for all the colourful notions people use of angels falling, they are at a loss for proving angels can sin. It's a ridiculous subject J. because the Word of God presents them as not being able to sin, or die.

Forcing mythology onto the text is typical of believers who love to have their ears tickled, if you get my drift.

F2F
I have Scripture that angels CAN sin brother but I don't want to disrupt our friendship.
And an interesting read from the rabbins re malachim.
Shalom.
J.
 
  • Like
Reactions: face2face

Lambano

Well-Known Member
Jul 13, 2021
8,541
11,659
113
Island of Misfit Toys
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Because there is no origin story for all the colourful notions people use of angels falling, they are at a loss for proving angels can sin.
Is dancing on the head of a pin a sin? Dancing was considered a sin in the Baptist church I attended as a teen.

Here's one dancing on the head of a bowling pin.

christensenhowmanyangels.jpg
 

face2face

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2015
8,243
1,202
113
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Is dancing on the head of a pin a sin? Dancing was considered a sin in the Baptist church I attended as a teen.

Here's one dancing on the head of a bowling pin.

christensenhowmanyangels.jpg
They don't need wings!...this is another example of man-made notions. Maybe these are strap on? Who knows we entertain them unawares Heb 13:2.
F2F
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Lambano

GodsGrace

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2017
14,082
7,310
113
Tuscany
Faith
Christian
Country
Italy
Good grief...more erroneous opinions? Try listening next time your “acquaintance” visits.
If you have gained such information from any JW I would be surprised. You can’t hear with your fingers in your ears....

We accept “Christian” doctrine but not “church” doctrine.....there is a vast difference. A little study will furnish the difference....not many are willing to put in the effort....just happy to be spoon fed what is easy.
Ditto.

We do accept that Jesus literally rose from the dead.....no one can dispute that.....but “how” he rose...in what “form” and “who” raised him, are clearly stated in the Bible....none of which are accepted in Christendom.
HOW
FORM
WHO
Regarding Jesus' resurrection.

BINGO!
What more need be said....

There was no other reason to deny access to “the tree of life”, other than to prevent the now sinful humans from living forever....imagine all the despots down through history if they never died...!

Immortality means “the power of an indestructible life”.....an immortal cannot die. If they were immortal, then the death penalty was a lie.

Happy to dispel whatever errors you are fond of promoting.....
So good of you....
But this won't be necessary.
 

GodsGrace

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2017
14,082
7,310
113
Tuscany
Faith
Christian
Country
Italy
As you wish……:IDK:

Catholic doctrine, which finds no scriptural support at all…and kept people in ignorance for some 1500 years…..is as follows….

1) The nature of God…..presenting the Almighty as three separate beings who can talk to one another, pray to one another, have a different will to the others, and who can be in three places at once.
He can be his own servant (Acts 4:27) His own apostle and High Priest, (Heb 3:1) as well as his own mediator. (1 Tim 2:5-6)

The Jews did not know such a God and neither did the first Christian….who were all Jewish.

2) The position of Mary in relation to Jesus….Mary is never said to be “the mother of God”, because as an uncreated being, God cannot have a mother. She was not immaculately conceived, nor was she taken to heaven bodily. She was as sinful as any other person born from Adam.

3) There is no immortal soul ever mentioned in the Bible. “Souls” are living, breathing creatures who depend on external means to continue living. All “souls, both animals and humans, depend on oxygen, food and water, which was supplied in abundance by the Creator, along with the “tree of life” which guaranteed that mortal human life could continue indefinitely, as long as they remained obedient. Once sin entered into their lives, the means to grant them unending life (the tree of life) was denied. (Gen 3:22-24)

4) The instrument used to put Christ to death is not called a cross in the Greek Scriptures…it is called a “stauros” which means an upright stake…it doesn’t not mean a cross piece of timber at any angle.…beside which fact, we are told not to make religious images of “anything”. (Ex 20:4-5)

It is a bizarre thing indeed to make an image of the instrument used to put someone you live to death…and venerate it…..yet that is what we see….on church buildings, as jewelry worn around the neck, or on prayer beads.…something else that was missing in the first century…..repetitious prayers.

The Catholic church took idolatry even further and made statues of their objects of veneration, bowing down to them, in complete contradiction to God’s instructions.

5) Infant baptism…this makes a mockery of what baptism signifies…..it is treated as some kind of lucky charm, sprinkling an infant with water and calling it baptism so that it won’t go to hell if it dies…..Nowhere is it even mentioned in the Bible. Jesus was 30 when he was baptized. One must fully understand the significance of baptism and it has to be chosen as a decision of the heart of individuals who have accepted Christ as their savior, and have made the decision themselves to become baptized as such….there is no proxy arrangement.

6) The condition of the dead, (as believed by Jews) was that humans “slept” in death until the promised resurrection, which was a return to life, not a continuation of it in another form….in another realm. (Eccl 9:5, 10) When Jesus raised his friend Lazarus, where did he say Lazarus was? (John 11:11-14)

Death is the opposite of life…..so who was it that suggested that we don’t really die? Wasn’t that the devil’s first lie? He makes people believe that the dead go to either heaven or hell when they die, the Catholic church added “purgatory” but there is no such place mentioned in the Bible.

Since there is no such thing as an immortal soul, we do not have to invent places for them to go….especially not burning in eternal flames as if God were some kind of fiendish torturer…..another satanic lie!

7) Pagan celebrations dressed up as “Christian” events. We are told not to mix true worship with false worship. When Israel tried to do that God punished them. If you remember the golden calf incident, the Israelites coerced Aaron into fashioning their gold into the same kind of god they saw worshipped in Egypt….they called it “a festival to the Lord”, but it was no such thing…it was plainly idolatry. God put the offenders to death. It’s not what you call it…it’s what or whom the original was in honor of……Christmas, Easter, Valentine’s Day, Halloween,……all of pagan origin but celebrated by the whole of Christendom. (2 Cor 6:14-18) God saw the originals….he hated them then…he hates them still.

8) There were no priests officiating in the Christian congregations of the first century. Those congregations had a body of elders who were shepherds of the flock, a role that was never left to just one man.
There were no fancy vestments or headgear, as Jesus himself demonstrated…..he was dressed like his disciples….the reason why Judas had to identify him with a kiss.

9) There were no titles either, just positions of service.
One title that was never to be given to any man was “Father” in the spiritual sense (Matt 23:9)……how is the pope addressed? How are Catholic priests addressed?
Where will I even find a pope in first century Christianity?

“E·piʹsko·pos”, from which the word “bishop” is derived, simply means an overseer. It wasn’t a title denoting a position of authority, but one of responsibility….in the church, “Bishop” and “Archbishop” came to mean men of authority, wielding power over others.

10) Forgiveness of sins was granted on the basis of repentance and the shed blood of Jesus Christ. No man was ever authorized to forgive sins except Jesus, who had no sin. (Luke 5:20-24)

No sinful human being has any sanction from God to hear a confession and offer absolution on the basis of repetitious words, as if God is pleased with such things. Praying to God must come from the heart, not the hands fingering some beads that prompt a repetitious mental response. Where did the rosary come from? Not Christ. Where did “indulgences” come from? Again not Christ.

That will do for now…..but hopefully, you get the picture of why I reject what came from apostate Christianity.….
Yes. Sorry I missed this.
Am I supposed to attempt to justify Christianity to you Auntie Jane?
All of the above are scriptural except for one doctrine,,,,which MIGHT be true, or might not.
Just as an example:
There were FIVE Popes by the 2nd century, but it began in the 1st century.
You, or anyone reading along, can look this up.
I'll tell you which areas they were Popes of and the rest is up to anyone intersted.
The rest of your list is just as bad, but, unless someone else writes and is interested in this, I won't be responding to you.
ROME
CONSTANTINOPLE
ALEXANDRIA
JERUSALEM
ANTIOCH

Learn some church history and maybe the hatred will leave your soul.
 

Aunty Jane

Well-Known Member
Sep 16, 2021
7,003
3,835
113
Sydney
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
FWIW….
Am I supposed to attempt to justify Christianity to you Auntie Jane?
No….but I was hoping for some scriptural evidence concerning the claim that Catholic doctrine is based on the Bible or the teachings of Christ and his apostles…you see anything outside of scripture is inadmissible.
You have a vastly different view of what constitutes “Christianity” than I do……if Christ was to return tomorrow, who would he accept as his own?
All of the above are scriptural except for one doctrine,,,,which MIGHT be true, or might not.
Please supply the scriptures that back up this claim or it is empty…again, you are in a debate forum so where is your rebuttal? Evidence is needed to back up what you say. It’s not about your opinions.
Just as an example:
There were FIVE Popes by the 2nd century, but it began in the 1st century.
You, or anyone reading along, can look this up.
Five “popes” you say….? Where will I find them in Scripture? Do tell….did they all carry the pagan Roman title of Pontifex Maximus? According to my research, Julius Caesar held this title more than 40 years before Jesus was born. How strange if it was a “Christian” title…..?
I'll tell you which areas they were Popes of and the rest is up to anyone intersted.
There were no “popes” in original Christianity…..nor were there any earthly priests officiating in the congregations. The priesthood of Christ’s apostles and disciples was to be served in heaven…not on earth. (Rev 20:6)
The rest of your list is just as bad, but, unless someone else writes and is interested in this, I won't be responding to you.
Well, as I said before, this is a debate forum, so if you are not willing to debate, then why are you here?
There is a difference between being unwilling to respond.…and unable.
If you have the courage of your convictions then a strong rebuttal should be a walk in the park….just keep it scriptural as it is a Bible discussion forum.
ROME
CONSTANTINOPLE
ALEXANDRIA
JERUSALEM
ANTIOCH

Learn some church history and maybe the hatred will leave your soul.
Perhaps you also need to do this…..just don’t accept your pagan church’s word for anything….they have never preached the truth in their entire existence. When Jesus comes as judge and says to those who profess to be his disciples….”I NEVER KNEW YOU”…he means it. (Matt 7:21-23)

When Catholic raised people become Jehovah’s Witnesses, they are generally appalled at the things they were taught that are contrary to what Jesus taught…..their lack of Bible knowledge and slavery to ritual, did not allow them to see the truth….but once the Scriptures were opened to them, and the light shone through the darkness…..they left the church in obedience to Rev 18:4-5…..Christendom as a whole, is part of “Babylon the great”, promoting beliefs that originated in ancient Babylon, the springboard for all false worship….it is not even a shadow of what the first century Christians believed. But unless you study the Bible itself, rather than church doctrine, you will never know.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheHC

TheHC

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2021
528
524
93
Columbus
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
2 Peter 2:4-6
Angels who sinned (2 Peter 2:4):
This likely refers to the fallen angels from Genesis 6:1-4 (the "sons of God" who came to the daughters of men) and possibly references extra-biblical Jewish tradition (like the Book of Enoch), where the sin of these angels is elaborated on.

Angels who did not keep their positions of authority (Jude 1:6):
Similar to 2 Peter, this is likely referencing the fallen angels from Genesis 6:1-4 or Jewish traditions about their rebellion.
Thanks, @Johann !

I wasn’t about to go over it again with F2F.

His unreasonable & arrogant attitude abrades me.

Take care, my cousin!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Johann