Davidpt
Well-Known Member
Exactly. Premils do not look at Revelation 20:6 carefully. They don't recognize that having part in the first resurrection is required in order to avoid the second death.
And it's not a bodily resurrection that makes it so that we avoid the second death. If that was the case, then those who are alive and remain unto the coming of the Lord wouldn't avoid the second death because they would not have part in the first resurrection in that case.
They don't think about the fact that the second death has no power over those who have spiritually had part in Christ's resurrection, which scripture says is the first resurrection (Acts 26:23, 1 Cor 15:20), and are saved. So, the souls of the dead in Christ that John saw in heaven already had part in the first resurrection before he sees them. The second death already had no power over them. Also, they are already priests of God and of Christ (Rev 1:5-6). So, Revelation 20:6 is talking about a current reality, not a future event.
Then if we toss NOSAS into the mix, what then? One can be blessed and holy one minute, have part in the first resurrection one minute where death has no power over them, then the next minute they are no longer blessed and holy somehow, the next minute they no longer have part in the first resurrection somehow, and somehow now the 2nd death has power over them, therefore, making everything John said in Revelation 20:6 untrue? There are no conditions attached to that verse making it possible to lose part in the first resurrection after having part in it. It means what it says. It means that every single person that has part in the first resurrection, the 2nd death has no power over them. The 2nd death involves everlasting death. The first resurrection involves everlasting life.
Your doctrine of Amil, maybe not Roger's doctrine of Amil, implies that some who have part in the first resurrection are going to get cast into the LOF. Thus making John a liar in Revelation 20:6 since he plainly said that everyone who has part in the first resurrection, the 2nd death has no power over them. Meaning it is impossible any of them can be cast into the LOF instead. Obviously, the 2nd death having no power over someone can't be the same thing as the 2nd death having power over someone.
What did John plainly say in Revelation 20:6?
Those who have part in the first resurrection, the 2nd death has no power over any of them.
Or did he say this instead?
Those who have part in the first resurrection, the 2nd death has power over some of them.
Anyone being honest with the text is not going to remotely choose the latter.