new version of OSAS?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Tong2020

Well-Known Member
Apr 30, 2020
4,854
848
113
*
Faith
Christian
Country
Philippines
Tong2020 said:
Justification before God is something that one gets to have, not by one’s doing this or that. For justification is of God and is according to His grace.
Correct in the sense, "Justification by God" IS NOT by one "DOING A WORK"...
Agree.

However "Justification by God" IS given a man because that one man has freely "MADE" a 'Choice'.

Glory to God,
Taken
May I ask, why or how was it that you get to choose to believe God?

Tong
R3805
 

farouk

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2009
30,788
19,235
113
North America
Abraham was justified because he obeyed God.

Wow.....How much “ guts” it must take to deliberately misquote the Bible in a Christian Discussion group ....” guts” that you will answer for someday...

“ Abraham BELIEVED God and it was counted for Righteousness”
Interesting that Paul in Romans in chapter 1 and chapter 16 speaks of 'obedience to the faith' and 'the obedience of faith'.

This is of course a long way from any supposed idea of earning salvation by works.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
27,358
14,803
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Ah.

So you went from being a sinner who continually sinned against god in every thing you did

To a super mature perfect believer who never does anything wrong.

You skipped the baby stage, and and all the other stages of learning to place your faith in Christ in all areas..

Is this what you are saying?

That is nothing what "I" said.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
27,358
14,803
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
The point remains, we don’t get to give God authority of any sort. He has all authority.

Tong
R3804

Does God, by His Authority, Save a man, Against the mans Own Want, Will, Authority...
To Be Made Saved?
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
27,358
14,803
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
May I ask, why or how was it that you get to choose to believe God?

Tong
R3805

By and Through what God Offers, Gives...
And man "chooses" to Take.

In the beginning, God Offered and Gave Adam "Gods Word".

Adam Choose to Take, some of what God Offered. We note when God brought the animals to Adam to name, and Adam "chose" to Name the animals.
Adam Chose to NOT Take Gods Word, when God Offered and Gave Adam warning to Not eat of a particular Tree.
Adam Chose to NOT Take Gods Word, when God Offered and Gave the Tree of Life for Adam TO eat, and Adam chose NOT to eat of the Tree of Life.

Freewill is mans authority to choose what is the mans will.
Men Choose, to Hear Gods Word, or NOT.
Men Choose, to Do What is Gods Word, or NOT.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GRACE ambassador

BloodBought 1953

Well-Known Member
Jun 3, 2020
5,032
1,821
113
72
Portsmouth Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
By and Through what God Offers, Gives...
And man "chooses" to Take.

In the beginning, God Offered and Gave Adam "Gods Word".

Adam Choose to Take, some of what God Offered. We note when God brought the animals to Adam to name, and Adam "chose" to Name the animals.
Adam Chose to NOT Take Gods Word, when God Offered and Gave Adam warning to Not eat of a particular Tree.
Adam Chose to NOT Take Gods Word, when God Offered and Gave the Tree of Life for Adam TO eat, and Adam chose NOT to eat of the Tree of Life.

Freewill is mans authority to choose what is the mans will.
Men Choose, to Hear Gods Word, or NOT.
Men Choose, to Do What is Gods Word, or NOT.


Anybody can “ hear” the Gospel.....Lest God “ open your heart” it will fall upon deaf ears.....

Check out the story of Lydia , the Seller Of Purple In Acts 16...... ( God “ opened her heart “ to not only “hear” it, but he opened her heart to “ Believe” it....This is in full agreement with the Truth Of this Statement — “ Nobody comes to God unless the Spirit draw him” ......it seems that God has the initiative when it comes to getting Saved—— only HE can bless one with “ ears to hear and eyes to see”......or in other words, the Opening Of a Heart.......
 
Last edited:

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
27,358
14,803
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Interesting that Paul in Romans in chapter 1 and chapter 16 speaks of 'obedience to the faith' and 'the obedience of faith'.

This is of course a long way from any supposed idea of earning salvation by works.

TO and OF, can be tricky.
Paul's preaching, was often the same as Jesus'. A mix of people.
Some already OF the Faith and listening.
Some obedient TO the faith, simply by making at point to go, and be among the crowd of listeners.
The first several verses of Romans 1, reveals the men in Rome who are OF the Faith (already believing) and others who are obedient TO the Faith, (who came to hear).

Glory to God,
Taken
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
27,358
14,803
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Anybody can “ hear” the Gospel.....Lest God “ open your heart” it will fall upon deaf ears.....

Check out the story of Lydia , the Seller Of Purple In Acts 16...... ( God “ opened her heart “ to not only “hear” it, but he opened her heart to “ Believe” it....This is in full agreement with the Truth Of this Statement — “ Nobody comes to God unless the Spirit draw him” ......it seems that God has the initiative when it comes to getting Saved—— only HE can bless one with “ ears to hear and eyes to see”......or in other words, the Opening Of a Heart.......

Point...was mans FREEWILL...anyone can Hear or Not.

You are making the Point of Gods Works.
 

Tong2020

Well-Known Member
Apr 30, 2020
4,854
848
113
*
Faith
Christian
Country
Philippines
Tong2020 said:
The point remains, we don’t get to give God authority of any sort. He has all authority.
Does God, by His Authority, Save a man, Against the mans Own Want, Will, Authority...
To Be Made Saved?
Any and all things that God does is by His authority.

Nobody gives God any authority. For He is the source of it. What authority you think man have, is only what man received from God. And when God gives, it does not mean God cease to not have said given authority.

<<<Does God, by His Authority, Save a man, Against the mans Own Want, Will, Authority...
To Be Made Saved?>>>

God saves man according to His will, pleasure, purpose, and divine nature. Needless to say, He has that power and authority.

Regarding your question, you have already been invited by @Blood Bought 1953, to check out the story of Lydia in Acts 16, how she was saved by God. And after checking that out, please tell us what you get to see there regarding man’s free will and God’s authority.

Tong
R3806
 
  • Like
Reactions: BloodBought 1953

Tong2020

Well-Known Member
Apr 30, 2020
4,854
848
113
*
Faith
Christian
Country
Philippines
Tong2020 said:
May I ask, why or how was it that you get to choose to believe God?
By and Through what God Offers, Gives...
And man "chooses" to Take.

In the beginning, God Offered and Gave Adam "Gods Word".

Adam Choose to Take, some of what God Offered. We note when God brought the animals to Adam to name, and Adam "chose" to Name the animals.
Adam Chose to NOT Take Gods Word, when God Offered and Gave Adam warning to Not eat of a particular Tree.
Adam Chose to NOT Take Gods Word, when God Offered and Gave the Tree of Life for Adam TO eat, and Adam chose NOT to eat of the Tree of Life.

Freewill is mans authority to choose what is the mans will.
Men Choose, to Hear Gods Word, or NOT.
Men Choose, to Do What is Gods Word, or NOT.
<<<By and Through what God Offers, Gives...
And man "chooses" to Take.>>>

Yes, man do have a choice. But what choice he have is only what choice is real to him. Meaning, one could only believe or not believe the gospel when he hears the gospel. Now, when the gospel comes to him, he could only believe or not believe what he gets to understand of the gospel. I think you know that the gospel is from God and is about the things of the Spirit of God. And I believe you have read Paul said that the natural man does not receive the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him, nor can he know them, because they are spiritually discerned. Now, considering that, what becomes of free will or having a choice? Unless God quickens the spirit of the natural man, opening his spiritual eyes and ears, he will not really understand the gospel. Now, we see people hear the gospel, and some receive it and some don’t, some believe and some don’t, isn’t it? Have you wondered how could some reject such an amazing grace? Again, check out the story of Lydia. So, let me ask again why or how was it that you get to choose to believe God? Do you think that came to be without God’s working in you such as He had with Lydia?

Tong
R3807
 
  • Like
Reactions: BloodBought 1953

Tong2020

Well-Known Member
Apr 30, 2020
4,854
848
113
*
Faith
Christian
Country
Philippines
Anybody can “ hear” the Gospel.....Lest God “ open your heart” it will fall upon deaf ears.....

Check out the story of Lydia , the Seller Of Purple In Acts 16...... ( God “ opened her heart “ to not only “hear” it, but he opened her heart to “ Believe” it....This is in full agreement with the Truth Of this Statement — “ Nobody comes to God unless the Spirit draw him” ......it seems that God has the initiative when it comes to getting Saved—— only HE can bless one with “ ears to hear and eyes to see”......or in other words, the Opening Of a Heart.......
Amen.

It is God who saves, according to His will, purpose, pleasure, and divine nature.

Tong
R3808
 
  • Like
Reactions: BloodBought 1953

farouk

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2009
30,788
19,235
113
North America
Back To Justification

I asked How many times was Abraham justified before God and what for....?

Was He Justified so that He can have heaven when He died? Even that is part of it?

Read Genesis 15
Abraham believed God for a son..
And in verse 6 He counted it for righteousness.

So His justification was for things concerning this life....
At a deep level, it was because of his faith that Abraham was justified. This is also a central message of Romans and Galatians with their strong themes of justification.
 

Corlove13

Active Member
Apr 30, 2021
746
171
43
56
Los Angeles
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Abraham was justified because he obeyed God.
Like Satan, OSAS do not obey God's commandments, making the excuse it is salvation by works.
They are not the children of God, but modern day Pharisees whose Father is the devil. John 8:44.
.
Sometimes what strangles and holds people is that we are in bondage of our ideals.
Therefore those Ideals have to be broken down.

Which is a point I am making here.....
Somethings have been passed down...that have never been examined, and have even been taken out of context....

Therefore many churches make converts but not disciples.

But interesting How Jesus says: Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the father, and of the son, and of the Holy Ghost: Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and, lo, I am with you always, even unto the end of the world. Amen.
Matthew 28:19


So how are they to teach?
By baptizing
I made a mistake and said, "Abraham was justified because he obeyed God." when I should have said "because he believed God."

The point I wanted to make is that belief on its own is not adequate, as I have said before, Satan believes in God and trembles. The sign of a true Christian believer is someone who obeys the Lord, keeps the commandments and lives a life that is pleasing to God, and that is what Abraham did. He obeyed God and lived a life pleasing to the Lord. What you might call a Holy Life. You say, it matters not what we do, we are always saved. I disagree if your life makes a mockery of the life Christ would have us live, what the Bible calls a righteous life. God loves a righteous person and not a licentious person. You need to put your house in order before it is too late. You could be killed in a car accident, have a heart attack, anything could happen, so drop all this false teaching and get yourself on the right path and follow the God of Abraham in the right and proper manner.
.
I believe when there is a command to repent and believe the Gospel....when you do such you obey the command to repent and believe.

But with the father of faith...we need to go back and read....which I will do...understanding that God told Abraham to walk before Him blameless and He would make a covenant with Him.........If Abraham walked in the path of righteousness ....then...a covenant then would be made.....so doesn't that mean Abraham was obedient to the command to walk b4 God Blameless sense the Covenant was eventually made with Abraham?....therefore to believe is to obey....
It's spiritual.....

Abraham believed with intent to follow...
And that was enough...for God to count Him righteous..

The key question though...is did it say Abraham was justified so He could have heaven when He died.....? Or was He justified for things concerning the life He was then living.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
27,358
14,803
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Any and all things that God does is by His authority.

No dispute.

Nobody gives God any authority.

By Gods Authority, Will, Pleasure, God Himself
"MADE" man to have Freewill...
Freewill IS mans ability to Freely Choose.
A man Freely Choosing God, or NOT Choosing God: IS a man exercising his own individual (power/authority) TO CHOOSE.

You are implying, WITHOUT a mans...
Freewill, Authority, Okay, Agreement, Consent...
THAT God Himself WILL "By HIS AUTHORITY" Force a man to Choose God.

Uh, no.

For He is the source of it. What authority you think man have, is only what man received from God.

I Already established that. Expressly noting God MADE man to HAVE FREEWILL.

And when God gives, it does not mean God cease to not have said given authority.

Never said, Gods Authority ceases.

God saves man according to His will, pleasure, purpose, and divine nature.

Sure He does, never said otherwise.
Before my life time, God Offered TO THE WHOLE WORLD, Freewill, To Choose God, or NOT.
And God expressly revealed How a man CAN (according to Gods Way, ie terms) choose God.
And God Promised, that ANY man WHO expressly chooses God according to His WAY, God WILL Save that man....which IS expressly According to His WILL.

Needless to say, He has that power and authority.

And seemingly necessary to repeat...
God gave man the authority to FREELY CHOOSE God or Not.


Tong
R3806
[/QUOTE]
 

Corlove13

Active Member
Apr 30, 2021
746
171
43
56
Los Angeles
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
At a deep level, it was because of his faith that Abraham was justified. This is also a central message of Romans and Galatians with their strong themes of justification.
Thank you, what I am trying to challenge is Osaser's ideals about being Justified once...

Because of how many were evangelized...to trust what Jesus did as the Foundation....in order[in the way they see it]to have heaven when they die..

Although heaven when you die is important.. and what Jesus did is important...

The Foundation is....Trusting Who He is....
The Son of God...with the intent to follow.
Another words....if He is your savior....should not He be also your Lord?

I speak of myself and to many others evangelized as I was in this way:

Do you believe Jesus died for your sins and arose from the dead then you are saved .

That was the Gospel preached to me. But in Mark chapter 1 it spells out the Good news.

In verse 15
Jesus preached the Gospel of the kingdom.
"....The Kingdom of God is at hand."

Therefore what the disciple were preaching is what Jesus did so that they would trust Him as one who has say over everything. [As Lord, Master, ruler, creator of all things....etc

Therefore the Kingdom of the heavens is now available to enter on earth accepting the King for who God pronounce and did Miracles through. "Jesus".......
That means life in the kingdom we can live by now....this is how we through Christ destroy the works of the devil, and redeeming the body......Romans 8...there's more but you know this stuff....my phone doesn't want to type....

Point is the foundation is Christ....not what He did....What He did emphasized who He was....and where we can receive forgiveness and everything else we need.

Many OSASers start off with Justification...and link justification with regeneration....and there is the problem...
....Being born is a matter of...Believing who Jesus is.......The Eunich was baptized after believing Christ was the son of God....

So does forgiveness of Sin [justification] come before Regeneration? I DON'T THINK SO...
ANYWAY I SAID TOO MUCH...

PEACE AND BLESSINGS TO YOU
 
Last edited:

farouk

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2009
30,788
19,235
113
North America
Thank you, what I am trying to challenge is Osaser's ideals about being Justified once...

Because of how many were evangelized...to trust what Jesus did as the Foundation....in order[in the way they see it]to have heaven when they die..

Although heaven when you die is important..It and what Jesus dud os important...

The Foundation is....Trusting Who He is....
The Son of God...with the intent to follow.
Another words....if He us your savior....should not He be your Lord?

I speak of myself and to many others evangelized as I was in this way:

Do you believe Jesus died for your sins and arose from the dead then you are saved .

That was the Gospel preached to me. But in Mark chapter 1 it spells out the Good news.

In verse 15
Jesus preached the Gospel of the kingdom.
The Kingdom of God is at hand.

Therefore what the disciple were preaching is what Jesus did so that we/they would trust Him as one who has say over everything. [As Lord, Master, ruler, creator of all things....etc

Therefore the Kingdom of the heavens is now available to enter on earth accepting the King for who God pronounce and did Miracles through. "Jesus".......
That means life in the kingdom we can live by now....this is how we through Christ destroy the works of the devil, and redeeming the body......Romans 8...there's more but you know this stuff....my phone doesn't want to type....

Point is the foundation is Christ....not what He did....What He did emphasized whi He was....and where we can receive forgiveness...

Many OSASers start off with Justification...and link justification with regeneration....and there is the problem...
....Being born is a matter of...Believing who Jesus is.......The Eunich was baptized after believing Christ was the son of God....
So does forgiveness of Sin [justification] come before Regeneration? I DON'T THINK SO...
ANYWAY I SAID TOO MUCH...

PEACE AND BLESSINGS TO YOU
I don't believe in baptismal regeneration, anyway; I confess I have not read all the posts on this thread, so I don't necessarily understand where ppl are coming from...
 

Corlove13

Active Member
Apr 30, 2021
746
171
43
56
Los Angeles
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I don't believe in baptismal regeneration, anyway; I confess I have not read all the posts on this thread, so I don't necessarily understand where ppl are coming from...
WELL I am not talking....about...Baptism in that light.......nor 4 that purpose.....what I was tipping off to was.....what baptism is said to mean......In my opinion....people take on Baptism after they believed a certain teaching....also Baptism has different meanings.....depending one the context.
As I believe the so called "great commission "
I do not believe that is referring to water there. The Baptism in the red sea...the Israelites never got touched by the water...
Anyway...just some thoughts...I am studying.
 

Taken

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2018
27,358
14,803
113
United States
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Regarding your question, you have already been invited by @Blood Bought 1953, to check out the story of Lydia in Acts 16, how she was saved by God. And after checking that out, please tell us what you get to see there regarding man’s free will and God’s authority.

Tong
R3806

Pretty Clear. Paul and Timothy, on the sabbath went out from a city they had been staying in (during their travels), to a river side, to pray.
When they arrived at the river side there was a woman there, named Lydia, (who sold purple things in the city). Lydia worshipped God. Paul and Timothy sat and talk with Lydia. ( I can presume Paul and Timothy talked with her ABOUT Jesus Christ, since that is what Paul agreed with Jesus he would do, and Timothy agree with Paul that is what he would do). Lydia we learn, was Baptized.
* Nothing says Lydia was forced to worship God, but she did Worship God.
* Nothing says Lydia rejected what Paul and Timothy was telling her.
* Every indication is Lydia FREELY CHOSE, by her own Consent, her free will authority TO Consent, to give her life to the Lord God and receive the Offering of His Baptism, His Conversion.


Act 16
[13] And on the sabbath we went out of the city by a river side, where prayer was wont to be made; and we sat down, and spake unto the women which resorted thither.
[14] And a certain woman named Lydia, a seller of purple, of the city of Thyatira, which worshipped God, heard us: whose heart the Lord opened, that she attended unto the things which were spoken of Paul.
[15] And when she was baptized, and her household, she besought us, saying, If ye have judged me to be faithful to the Lord, come into my house, and abide there. And she constrained us.


You are hung up on "authority".
Every man WHO, Freely willfully, consents, agrees, IS Authorizing God to DO HIS WORKS, He Offered He WOULD DO....
IF a man Consents.

Men require your "WRITTEN" authorization,
To AGREEMENTS, CONTRACTS, CONSENTS...
(BEFORE, they are oblidged to DO what they Offer... Employment, Banking, Attorney, etc.)

God Requires your "WORD" authorization,
(BEFORE, He is oblidged to DO what He Offered...Forgiveness, Salvation, Quickening, etc.)