Do Joseph Smith and Ellen White fir Bibal criteria of a true Prophet?

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Jane_Doe22

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2018
5,412
3,552
113
117
Mid-west USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Only meant anything that leads to vanity, even in myself...that is why “they teach for hire” stands out, more as a question of am I guilty of doing the same? For hire, paraphrasing where the word says ...yet we have not used (abused)this power over you but instead suffer all things for your sake.
Well said indeed and a important thing to remember.
In my experience, the two most common idols are greed and pride. It's important to remember to be humble, keep God at the head at all times.
 

JesusFan1

Active Member
Jun 19, 2020
413
133
43
64
Macomb Mi
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I know that this will most likely fall on deaf ears, but I'll explain it anyways. If anyone wants me to cite sources here, just ask:

If you talking Christology, here's a comparative blurb--

LDS Christians and Athanasian Christians (aka Christians that believe the Athanasian Creed) both believe:
Every single word about Christ in the Bible.
The Son of God, Jesus Christ is 100% divine.
The Father is 100% divine.
The Holy Spirit is 100% divine.
The Father, Son, and Spirit are all without beginning nor end.
The Father is not the Son, nor vice verse. Christ doesn’t pray to Himself. Neither of them are the Spirit. They are 3 different persons.
The Father, Son, and Spirit together are 1 God (are monotheists).
Christ was/is the great I Am, the Only Begotten Son of God.
Christ was one with the Father before the Earth was created. He then created the Earth, was born of a virgin, lived a mortal life with lots of suffering, took the world’s sins upon Himself, died on a cross, rose again on the 3rd day, later rose to heaven, and is coming back again.

The difference comes in:
LDS Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Spirit are 1 God through unity.
Athanasian Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Spirit are 1 God through consubstantiation (Consubstantiality - Wikipedia).

What difference does this make in the day to day:
Very little. Realistically, a lot of people sitting in Trinitarians pews have never even heard of the Athanasian Creed. This is a level of deeper theology which doesn’t affect day-to-day.



If you want to specifically about the Father:
Like Athanasian Christians, LDS Christians believe that the Spirit is a person of Spirit. The Son has a spirit, which inhabits a body of flesh, once mortal but now resurrected and glorified. Obviously having the body in no way diminishes the Son's glory or Godliness. The Bible is mute on to the specifics of the Father. Athanasian Christians generally believe that He's like the Spirit (just a spirit), LDS Christians that He's like the Son (a spirit in a gloried body).



If you want to talk salvation:
LDS Christians believe that salvation is a gift from God, received via faith. You don't get it via "works" or "earning" it-- such an idea is laughably impossible. However, faith without works is indeed dead, as a disciple of Christ should indeed strive to follow Him -- empowered by Him, and with repentance when screw ups happen. LDS Christians very firmly believe this.


If you want to talk crown in Heaven:
LDS Christians do indeed believe that Christ's atonement is miraculously powerful as to take crimson strained wretched sinners and transform them into pure white perfected saints of the Lord. 100% pure white, even as He is and joint-heirs with Christ. God's atonement is just that incredible. Even when fully crowned and as perfected as He is, obviously the Father will always be the Father, and the Savior still our Savior. Just is a testament to God's majesty, and should never be trivialized or cartoon-ized... such is just disrespectful to God.
Mormons hold to there being 3 gods, while we hold to there being just One...

We hold that God was eternally God, Mormons that he evolved into being God, as all good and faithful mormons males have that opportunity also!
 

Jane_Doe22

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2018
5,412
3,552
113
117
Mid-west USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Mormons hold to there being 3 gods, while we hold to there being just One...

We hold that God was eternally God, Mormons that he evolved into being God, as all good and faithful mormons males have that opportunity also!
Your statements here are not accurate. I’ve explained this several times.
 

Marymog

Well-Known Member
Mar 7, 2017
11,946
1,795
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As the Lord required that who ever was a true Prophey from Him would be among the brothers of Israel, in line of Isaac, would not undo or contridict any prior revelations, would know and use the name of God, and would either fo verified miracles or prophecy!

Do they qualify?
No
 

amadeus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2008
23,235
33,182
113
81
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Mormons hold to there being 3 gods, while we hold to there being just One...

We hold that God was eternally God, Mormons that he evolved into being God, as all good and faithful mormons males have that opportunity also!
And if we are selfish in our ways, does it matter whether we believe in One God, or a three in one God, or in three gods? Did Jesus teach us to first become aware of those three options, if any, are correct... or did he teach this?

"But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you." Matt 6:33
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pearl

Prayer Warrior

Well-Known Member
Sep 20, 2018
5,789
5,783
113
U.S.A.
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I know that this will most likely fall on deaf ears, but I'll explain it anyways. If anyone wants me to cite sources here, just ask:

If you talking Christology, here's a comparative blurb--

LDS Christians and Athanasian Christians (aka Christians that believe the Athanasian Creed) both believe:
Every single word about Christ in the Bible.
The Son of God, Jesus Christ is 100% divine.
The Father is 100% divine.
The Holy Spirit is 100% divine.
The Father, Son, and Spirit are all without beginning nor end.
The Father is not the Son, nor vice verse. Christ doesn’t pray to Himself. Neither of them are the Spirit. They are 3 different persons.
The Father, Son, and Spirit together are 1 God (are monotheists).
Christ was/is the great I Am, the Only Begotten Son of God.
Christ was one with the Father before the Earth was created. He then created the Earth, was born of a virgin, lived a mortal life with lots of suffering, took the world’s sins upon Himself, died on a cross, rose again on the 3rd day, later rose to heaven, and is coming back again.

The difference comes in:
LDS Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Spirit are 1 God through unity.
Athanasian Christians believe that the Father, Son, and Spirit are 1 God through consubstantiation (Consubstantiality - Wikipedia).

What difference does this make in the day to day:
Very little. Realistically, a lot of people sitting in Trinitarians pews have never even heard of the Athanasian Creed. This is a level of deeper theology which doesn’t affect day-to-day.



If you want to specifically about the Father:
Like Athanasian Christians, LDS Christians believe that the Spirit is a person of Spirit. The Son has a spirit, which inhabits a body of flesh, once mortal but now resurrected and glorified. Obviously having the body in no way diminishes the Son's glory or Godliness. The Bible is mute on to the specifics of the Father. Athanasian Christians generally believe that He's like the Spirit (just a spirit), LDS Christians that He's like the Son (a spirit in a gloried body).



If you want to talk salvation:
LDS Christians believe that salvation is a gift from God, received via faith. You don't get it via "works" or "earning" it-- such an idea is laughably impossible. However, faith without works is indeed dead, as a disciple of Christ should indeed strive to follow Him -- empowered by Him, and with repentance when screw ups happen. LDS Christians very firmly believe this.


If you want to talk crown in Heaven:
LDS Christians do indeed believe that Christ's atonement is miraculously powerful as to take crimson strained wretched sinners and transform them into pure white perfected saints of the Lord. 100% pure white, even as He is and joint-heirs with Christ. God's atonement is just that incredible. Even when fully crowned and as perfected as He is, obviously the Father will always be the Father, and the Savior still our Savior. Just is a testament to God's majesty, and should never be trivialized or cartoon-ized... such is just disrespectful to God.

Hi, Jane, what you've written here really doesn't give a complete picture of Mormon doctrine. You didn't mention anything about the LDS belief that God the Father was once a man of flesh and bones. And I have never read an explanation from you regarding LDS beliefs about the temple rituals, and you cannot give complete info about it without breaking an oath of silence. There are many other points of doctrine where Mormonism contradicts basic Bible doctrine....
.
 

Joseph77

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2020
5,673
1,325
113
Tulsa, OK
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As the Lord required that who ever was a true Prophey from Him would be among the brothers of Israel, in line of Isaac, would not undo or contridict any prior revelations, would know and use the name of God, and would either fo verified miracles or prophecy!

Do they qualify?
Does anyone in the last 500 years qualify ?
 

Jane_Doe22

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2018
5,412
3,552
113
117
Mid-west USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Hi, Jane, what you've written here really doesn't give a complete picture of Mormon doctrine. You didn't mention anything about the LDS belief that God the Father was once a man of flesh and bones. And I have never read an explanation from you regarding LDS beliefs about the temple rituals, and you cannot give complete info about it without breaking an oath of silence. There are many other points of doctrine where Mormonism contradicts basic Bible doctrine....
.
I literally just talked about the Father having body:
If you want to specifically about the Father:
Like Athanasian Christians, LDS Christians believe that the Spirit is a person of Spirit. The Son has a spirit, which inhabits a body of flesh, once mortal but now resurrected and glorified. Obviously having the body in no way diminishes the Son's glory or Godliness. The Bible is mute on to the specifics of the Father. Athanasian Christians generally believe that He's like the Spirit (just a spirit), LDS Christians that He's like the Son (a spirit in a gloried body).

If you want to talk about temple rites, sure we can totally talk about that. Conversation starts with salvation is via faith:
If you want to talk salvation:
LDS Christians believe that salvation is a gift from God, received via faith. You don't get it via "works" or "earning" it-- such an idea is laughably impossible. However, faith without works is indeed dead, as a disciple of Christ should indeed strive to follow Him -- empowered by Him, and with repentance when screw ups happen. LDS Christians very firmly believe this.
 

Joseph77

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2020
5,673
1,325
113
Tulsa, OK
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
And if we are selfish in our ways, does it matter whether we believe in One God, or a three in one God, or in three gods? Did Jesus teach us to first become aware of those three options, if any, are correct... or did he teach this?

"But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you." Matt 6:33
Does Jesus teach anyone anywhere today ?
 

Joseph77

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2020
5,673
1,325
113
Tulsa, OK
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As Jesus Says: Yahweh is Spirit.

No parts. Not a human. Not flesh. Not of this world. No body.
 

Jane_Doe22

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2018
5,412
3,552
113
117
Mid-west USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
As Jesus Says: Yahweh is Spirit.

No parts. Not a human. Not flesh. Not of this world. No body.
Again:
Like Athanasian Christians, LDS Christians believe that the Spirit is a person of Spirit. The Son has a spirit, which inhabits a body of flesh, once mortal but now resurrected and glorified. Obviously having the body in no way diminishes the Son's glory or Godliness. The Bible is mute on to the specifics of the Father. Athanasian Christians generally believe that He's like the Spirit (just a spirit), LDS Christians that He's like the Son (a spirit in a gloried body).
 

Joseph77

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2020
5,673
1,325
113
Tulsa, OK
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
When lds, catholic, protestant, or independent "beliefs" conflict with truth, do not agree with all Scripture,
they are not accepted nor acceptable.
 

Joseph77

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2020
5,673
1,325
113
Tulsa, OK
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
When lds, catholic, protestant, or independent "beliefs" conflict with truth, do not agree with all Scripture,
they are not accepted nor acceptable.
 

amadeus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2008
23,235
33,182
113
81
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Does Jesus teach anyone anywhere today ?
"And so it is written, The first man Adam was made a living soul; the last Adam was made a quickening spirit." I Cor 15:45

Anyone being quickened or having the words they consume from the scriptures quickened in them are being taught indeed. Looking at the population of planet Earth or even at the numbers of those bearing the label of Christian, I suppose that only a few of those are being taught by Jesus, but even a few is more than none...

"To whom God would make known what is the riches of the glory of this mystery among the Gentiles; which is Christ in you, the hope of glory:" Col 1:27
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joseph77

Joseph77

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2020
5,673
1,325
113
Tulsa, OK
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Looking at the population of planet Earth or even at the numbers of those bearing the label of Christian, I suppose that only a few of those are being taught by Jesus, but even a few is more than none...
Leonard Ravenhill Quotes (Author of Why Revival Tarries)
author/quotes/159020.Leonard_Ravenhill
quotes from Leonard Ravenhill:
'A man who is intimate with God is not intimidated by man.',
'No man is greater than his prayer life. The pastor who is not praying is playing; the people who are not praying are straying.
We have many organizers, but few agonizers;
many players and payers, few pray-ers;
many singers, few clingers;
lots of pastors, few wrestlers;
many fears, few tears; much ...
Nobody else can give you a clean heart but God.

There's one thing we need above everything else; it's something we
don't talk about these days. We need a mighty avalanche of
conviction of sin.

We're living in an unprecedented day (when) evil is no longer evil.
We've changed the terminology-- iniquity is now infirmity;
wickedness is now weakness;

devilry is now deficiency.

David had one of the most blessed experiences in the world, and the
blessedness was that he was miserable about his sin.

Are we sorry for grieving the heart of God... for denying God the
right to own our personality... to own our mind... to own our
thoughts... to own our emotions? (If not) we're robbing God.

Jesus did not come into the world to make bad men good. He came into
the world to make dead men live!
Someone asked me, "Do you pray for the dead?" I said, "No, I preach
to them!"
I think every pew in every church is death row. Think
about that! They're dead! They sing about God; they talk about God,
but they're dead! They have no living relationship (with God).

We've got people today that are very happy to celebrate Christmas or
Easter or even Pentecost Sunday as long as nothing happens.


There's cancer in the church tonight!

One said, "If I lead somebody to Christ on the street, which church
should I send him to?" Sending someone to church today is like
taking a newborn baby and putting it in a refrigerator. I want a
place that vibrates with God, vibrates with eternity.



I want to see the house of God where it's open 24 hours a day so
people can come. We don't close the hospitals after eight hours a
day or the police station. Why should the churches be locked up tonight?

If you know a church on fire for God, tell me and I'll go. A church
where (after) you've gone in, you don't come out the same, believing
that God is there (and) you've been in His holy presence!

God is taking His hands off of America. We've had so much light and
we've rejected it.


The early church was married to poverty, prisons and persecutions.
Today, the church is married to prosperity, personality, and popularity.

How can you have a dead service with a living Christ?

Fifty years ago, you never heard of a divorce in the Christian
church.
You never (even) heard of marriage counseling in the
church... We're putting up with sin in the church.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amadeus

amadeus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2008
23,235
33,182
113
81
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
...
David had one of the most blessed experiences in the world, and the
blessedness was that he was miserable about his sin.
... Jesus did not come into the world to make bad men good. He came into
the world to make dead men live!
Someone asked me, "Do you pray for the dead?" I said, "No, I preach
to them!"
Give God the glory! Praise his name!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joseph77

Brakelite

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2020
9,899
7,170
113
Melbourne
brakelite.wordpress.com
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Very likely. It's very typical behavior of any "anti-" group.
Not always. @Prayer Warrior seems to have done her homework with regards LDS literature.
Did you know that Ellen White is the most prolufic woman writer in history? That she wrote 30 books and thousands of letters, manuscripts, newspaper articles and journals?
For anyone reading this, I recommend Steps to Christ. It's available free to download in PDF format on innumerable sites. Read through it as many times as you like to find a fault and we'll talk about it.
 

Jane_Doe22

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2018
5,412
3,552
113
117
Mid-west USA
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Not always. @Prayer Warrior seems to have done her homework with regards LDS literature.
No, she just read some anti junk that (like anti-SDA stuff) takes a couple of quotes completely out of context, spins facts through a funhouse mirror 6 times over, and then demonizes that fabrication.
Did you know that Ellen White is the most prolufic woman writer in history? That she wrote 30 books and thousands of letters, manuscripts, newspaper articles and journals?
For anyone reading this, I recommend Steps to Christ. It's available free to download in PDF format on innumerable sites. Read through it as many times as you like to find a fault and we'll talk about it.
I did indeed know that she was an extreme writer and have read some of her stuff (actual essays, not just quotes). I've also chatted with several SDA's about their beliefs as well. Obviously I don't agree with SDA theology, but I should still be respectful, factual, and have thoughtful conversations about things.
 
Last edited: