Exploring Trinitarian Logic

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Status
Not open for further replies.

ProDeo

Well-Known Member
Nov 20, 2024
626
529
93
50
Deventer
Faith
Christian
Country
Netherlands
Well, that's the mystery, isn't it. You're making a mistake by expecting your carnal mind to get it. Are you familiar with the verse that says to lean not on your own understanding....? Why is that? Because as scripture attests, the carnal mind of the natural man can't perceive the things of God, they must be spiritually discerned......the carnal mind is ENMITY against God. We need to just humbly receive what is written. Our heart can receive truth long before our mind is illuminated to it. That's why we are to be in the spirit (heart) and not the flesh (carnal mind). When we're in the flesh and carnal mind we can't please God.
Yes, spiritual understanding is the key.


This is a post of mine from a thread started by @APAK an Unitarian about the subject of the origin of evil and look how easily we agreed.

Dealing with sin, the devil in the first place, is God's business.

God knew everything on beforehand, and it seems (the Lamb slain) God was willing to pay the price for that.

Can you feel the love?

You don't even need John 10:30 and other passages.
 

Wrangler

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2021
18,228
7,600
113
56
Shining City on a Hill
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I'm trying to prove that 'Three Ones equaling One', is not an Illogical Concept, as is often said...

As far as the last Equations go, %100 x %100 =1; done on a Calculator, adds up. Same goes for 1x1x1=1 and for 1÷1÷1=1...
What is illogical is you multiplying and dividing rather than adding or subtracting. It is also illogical to stop multiplying or dividing by 3.
 

Hey You!

Member
Feb 1, 2025
276
91
28
58
Auburn
www.facebook.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
What is illogical is you multiplying and dividing rather than adding or subtracting. It is also illogical to stop multiplying or dividing by 3.
I'll just say this once, since I'm New; if you want to talk, be nice to me. Otherwise I'll speak to Others. I've been doing this for awhile, I'm not here to argue. I don't Mind writing hit and run Posts...

The more you see me around, the more you may like to discuss things...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hepzibah

Wrangler

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2021
18,228
7,600
113
56
Shining City on a Hill
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I'll just say this once, since I'm New; if you want to talk, be nice to me.
Nothing I wrote was not nice. Just pointing out the anti-logic of trinitarianism. Tri does not mean 1.

It’s not logical to start with your conclusion, then try to rationalize it. This is called Circular Reasoning. Scripture teaches there is one God, the Father. Trinitarianism contradicts what Scripture teaches. Accepting as true a contradiction is illogical. Simple. And nice.
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
He certainly was in one accord with the Father.......but also at the same time it goes deeper in meaning. We need to look at scripture in light of other scriptures. Because for example, Jesus also said elsewhere that if you have seen me you have seen the Father.
You do realize sister . You do realize jus who you are speaking too .
A solider of trumps interfaith . this people has its hopes in the earthen
and the earthen shall all be dissolved and all whose hope was in men along with it .
They see as THEY desire to see sister . Did you know that for all my warnings
NOT A ONE who has went that direction has YET to repent and actaully i have seen some of them getting worse too .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marvelloustime

GodsGrace

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2017
14,082
7,310
113
Tuscany
Faith
Christian
Country
Italy
I've just now wanted to return to Action on Christian Debate Forums, so I joined here. It got so bad when I was on CARM, that I lost interest: no one cared about my good points...

So I gave up...
Right. Most are pretty darn bad.
It's a shame that we call ourselves Christian and come here only to argue ... different from debating.
But you're going to find all types wherever you go..so yes, speak only to those you're comfortable with.
I like to speak also to those from whom I can learn something. There's always something new to learn.
And, there's those reading along that you never even know about....so your good points will always be important.
Remember those reading along...
Take a break every now and then and recharge...some on these forums make this necessary - unfortunately.
Don't give up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hey You!

CadyandZoe

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2020
7,696
2,630
113
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
God is a being.
OK

The question is this: Is the Word an attribute?
According to Trinitarianism, God exists as one being (theological term "osia") consisting of three persons. So yes, each member of the Trinity is an aspect of the Godhead.
Let me ask you this: Is your mind an attribute of yours?
Yes, my mind is one of my attributes. But we are not talking about you and me. The discussion concerns the logic of Trinitarianism.

Or is what your mind wills, believes, etc. the attribute?
No. My mind and will are my attributes. Thought and belief are products of my mind.
Would you say, more likely, that your mind is a part of your being?
Not only is it likely, my mind is an attribute of my being. Nevertheless, one can not understand the Trinity using human beings as an analogy because the Trinitarian view of God sees God as one being comprised of three people, each with their own mind, will, and thoughts. We have nothing like that in our experience.
You apparently are not familiar with a Christian teaching called Divine Simplicity.
I am.
You say that "an attribute of a thing is not the thing itself".
Right....a thing has many attributes.
This is true in PHILOSOPHY.

We're in THEOLOGY here....
In theology God IS the thing itself.
I agree that by definition, God is the thing itself in Trinitarianism.
God does not come in parts the way we humans do.
He is a whole and cannot be separated from Himself.
I agree, which is why I don't affirm the validity of Trinitarianism.
GOD IS LOVE.

Love is NOT an attribute of God the way YOU are understanding it.
God IS ALL OF HIS ATTRIBUTES....
NOT SEPARATED...
BUT IN THE WHOLE.
I see no reason to believe that John was defining God as Love.
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Yes, spiritual understanding is the key.


This is a post of mine from a thread started by @APAK an Unitarian about the subject of the origin of evil and look how easily we agreed.

Dealing with sin, the devil in the first place, is God's business.

God knew everything on beforehand, and it seems (the Lamb slain) God was willing to pay the price for that.

Can you feel the love?

You don't even need John 10:30 and other passages.
I noticed a thread that said will the source of all evil please stand up .
Friend if all under the influence of the source of all evil were to stand
Most churches would be standing with open applause .
WE JUS GOTS NO IDEA
the depths of what is really going on and has been going on and specially as of late .
THE HOUR is late friend , VERY late and the delusion has come to take all the decieved
captive to a love they think is of GOD . friend it cannot be stopped .
Beleive me if i could i would burn every book written that supports its love . I would stand
and do all to rid this earth and most all of christendom of its false love .
BUDDY i cant do it , and i cannot stop it . IT WILL RUN ITS COURSE and take every captive to the love it claims be of GOD
and yet IT BE OF SATAN . all i can do is warn my friend . all i can do is warn and remind all TO BIBLE THE HECK UP and fast .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marvelloustime

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Well, Wm Lane Craig lives on syllogisms and so I'd say THEOLOGY.
As far as I can tell, practically everything refers to the study of God.
a love has captivated just about the entire realm of christendom now .
The problem is its mother is the harlot and its daddy the devil .
The delusion has been sent and it has come to merge the decieved of christendom
along with all the false religoins to believe in a love they all BELIEVE IS OF GOD .
ITS OF SATAN . and frankly i dont give a rip one what folks thinks about me for warning against
it and its many many methods by which it works .
REMEMBER THIS . REMEMBER THIS .
WE SHOULD HAVE LOVED GOD CHRIST FIRST ABOVE ALL
WE SHOULD HAVE HONORED HIM
and not put humanity before him . Many cannot stand me my friend
but i must continue by grace to do all i can no matter how hated it makes me of those i do love and desire only good for my friend .
Remember Any who loveth anyone or anything BEFORE GOD , BEFORE CHRIST
IS NOT WORTHY and i gaurantee no matter how much they said love and HIS NAME , THEY GONNA BE TOLD
I NEVER KNEW YOU . you remember this my dear friend . We have GOT to BIBLE UP RIGHT NOW without delay
and start afresh and anew in that bible for our own darn selves cause As the grains of sand are the decievers within
Even CHRISTENDOM itself . that might seem real hard to beleive . FRIEND its true . GET THIS PEOPLE BACK INTO THE BIBLE
now .
 

CadyandZoe

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2020
7,696
2,630
113
Phoenix
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
You do the same if you wish to call yourself a Christian.
I am a Christian. The difference between me and an Orthodox Christian is that I do not affirm some of the doctrines that are considered "orthodox." An Orthodox Christian believes in the Trinity Doctrine and the Deity of Jesus. I don't believe these doctrines because they aren't Biblical. They were invented by people living in the fourth century, based on Plato and Aristotle's view of reality, which, as it turns out, is incorrect.
Does Immanuel mean GOD WITH US?
Yes. The debate is over what it means to be "with us." I take my cues from Isaiah where the term was first established. In that context, the phrase "God with us" -- Immanuel -- means God is for us. He is working the good on our behalf. He will bless us and protect us from our enemies.
You tell me to study what THE SON OF GOD means.
Technically, I encouraged you to study the background of the phrase.
Let me ask you this:

If it means so little...which is apparently what you're stating...
I don't think I diminished it's meaning.
then WHY was Jesus killed for this.....the High Priest calling Him a blasphemer (Mark 14:64)
As I said, the Jews believe that the Messiah would be an angel or a theophany. So when Jesus, being a man, claimed to be the Messiah, they wrongly assumed that Jesus was claiming to be an angel or a theophany.

But Jesus wasn't killed because the Jews were righteously enforcing the Law. They acted out of hatred and fear because as they said, they were afraid that he would take away their place. The blaspheme charge was trumped up and false.
and WHY was Stephen stones for using the same expression?
Stephen was stoned because he embarrassed his accusers, bringing their hypocrisy and corruption to light.
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Well, Wm Lane Craig lives on syllogisms and so I'd say THEOLOGY.
As far as I can tell, practically everything refers to the study of God.
seems as though the liberal progressive mindset has taken hold of most all of christendom now .
Every time i turn around i see a new word . syllogisms .
You know what i dont see , THE ACTUAL WORD and WORDS OF GOD being taught .
That outta tell us all something RIGHT THERE .
WHY is it we seem to have the most intellectual sounding generation within christendom
Always learning , always learning
BUT MAN I DONT SEE MUCH BIBLE and that DOCTRINE
and if or when i do words quickly come that say exegis , this or that .
WOULD you like to know what i have noticed about these very very scholary and highly educated
folks that almost invent a word a day . THEY SURE SEEM TO NOT KNOW THE BIBLE at all .
they seem to use these words as a means to TWIST what is written to fit what THEY BELEIVE .
OH i just summed up the problem . GET THIS PEOPLE IN the BIBLE my friend .
 

GodsGrace

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2017
14,082
7,310
113
Tuscany
Faith
Christian
Country
Italy
According to Trinitarianism, God exists as one being (theological term "osia") consisting of three persons. So yes, each member of the Trinity is an aspect of the Godhead.

Yes, my mind is one of my attributes. But we are not talking about you and me. The discussion concerns the logic of Trinitarianism.


No. My mind and will are my attributes. Thought and belief are products of my mind.

Not only is it likely, my mind is an attribute of my being. Nevertheless, one can not understand the Trinity using human beings as an analogy because the Trinitarian view of God sees God as one being comprised of three people, each with their own mind, will, and thoughts. We have nothing like that in our experience.

I am.

I agree that by definition, God is the thing itself in Trinitarianism.

I agree, which is why I don't affirm the validity of Trinitarianism.

I see no reason to believe that John was defining God as Love.
Come back when you know what Divine Simplicity is and
not when you're THINKING you know what it is because the above shows that you do not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amigo de christo

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Come back when you know what Divine Simplicity is and
not when you're THINKING you know what it is because the above shows that you do not.
Folks do NOT know the bible at all . most know only what their theologians , systems
denominations , men taught them .
WE have got to get this people back into JUST reading the bible for themselves .
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Come back when you know what Divine Simplicity is and
not when you're THINKING you know what it is because the above shows that you do not.
Friend those whose love is for THE TRUTH , FOR GOD , FOR CHRIST above all
would have loved HIS words .
YOU would even marvel at HOW easy it is to see
THAT GOD was THE WORD .
There are so many things JESUS said that even shows us this .
ITS all over the bible . GOD IS HIS WORD , HE IS HIS SPIRIT , HE IS TRUTH , HE IS LIFE , HE IS WISDOM
And JESUS is All of this . I seen wisdom speaking
in proverbs chapter eight .
HE POSSESED ME in the beginning .
I was before anything that was created .
Read proverbs eight again . THEN lets ask the DENIERS OF JESUS
AT WHAT TIME did GOD HAVE TO CREATE HIS OWN WISDOM . HE IS WISDOM
I seen one trying to use an newer version that said in the beginning He created me ,
but that version is wrong .
I mean lets get serious . AT WHAT TIME did GOD LACK WISDOM and then have to CREATE IT .
JESUS IS THE WISDOM OF GOD , HE IS THE WORD
AND unto us HE is made the wisdom of GOD .
JESUS IS LIFE ITSELF as GOD IS LIFE
As HE IS HIS WORD , AS HE IS HIS SPIRIT ,
Folks act like we preach three gods . NO SIR . WE PREACH ONE GOD . ITs just HE IS HIS WORD , HE IS HIS SPIRIT .
AND JESUS IS THE WORD . as HE well said in revelation , I AM ALPHA and OMEGA the beginning and the end .
 

GodsGrace

Well-Known Member
Aug 29, 2017
14,082
7,310
113
Tuscany
Faith
Christian
Country
Italy
I am a Christian.
You CANNOT be a CHRISTian unless you believe Jesus is God.
That is the very definition of Christian.

You might be a Witness or a Mormon or who knows what else..
but you are NOT a Christian person.

The difference between me and an Orthodox Christian is that I do not affirm some of the doctrines that are considered "orthodox." An Orthodox Christian believes in the Trinity Doctrine and the Deity of Jesus. I don't believe these doctrines because they aren't Biblical.
Here's the problem C....
I'm saying that you should go study some church history.
Find out what was believed by the Apostles and all those that came after them.
Thomas exclaimed MY LORD AND MY GOD....
and Jesus did not correct him.

Those that came after ALSO believed Jesus was God.

So, tell us, why should we believe YOU when you state plainly that you don't believe in orthodox Christianity.
Believing in orthodox Christianity is WHAT MAKES YOU CHRISTIAN.

You don't get to make up your own rules.
The rules have already been established and by your own words you do NOT accept them.

So do Christianity a favor and stop calling yourself one.
They were invented by people living in the fourth century, based on Plato and Aristotle's view of reality, which, as it turns out, is incorrect.
Wow. So Christianity is based on Plato and Aristotle.
No comment.

You might want to post some supporting proof of this outlandish claim.

Yes. The debate is over what it means to be "with us." I take my cues from Isaiah where the term was first established. In that context, the phrase "God with us" -- Immanuel -- means God is for us. He is working the good on our behalf. He will bless us and protect us from our enemies.
You DID notice that Jesus was born?
IMMANUEL....a title as you must surely know.
GOD WITH US.

Matthew 1:23
20But when he had considered this, behold, an angel of the Lord appeared to him in a dream, saying, “Joseph, son of David, do not be afraid to take Mary as your wife; for the Child who has been conceived in her is of the Holy Spirit.
21She will bear a Son; and you shall call His name Jesus, for He will save His people from their sins.”

22Now all this took place to fulfill what was spoken by the Lord through the prophet:
23“BEHOLD, THE VIRGIN SHALL BE WITH CHILD AND SHALL BEAR A SON, AND THEY SHALL CALL HIS NAME IMMANUEL,” which translated means, “GOD WITH US.”


This is the fulfillment of the prophecy in
Isaiah 7:14
14“Therefore the Lord Himself will give you a sign: Behold, a virgin will be with child and bear a son, and she will call His name Immanuel.

In verse 22 of Matthew, he states that this is the fulfillment of the prophecy.


I think we should learn from Matthew.
I think he knew the OT and prophecy much better than we do.
Technically, I encouraged you to study the background of the phrase.

I don't think I diminished it's meaning.
Well, of course you did!

Jesus and Stephen died for using the term SON OF GOD.

YOU, otoh, claim that it doesn't mean much.
You are DIMINISHING its meaning.

Why diminish what early believers DIED FOR??

Because YOU cannot accept the tenets of Christianity....even though you
insist on calling yourself a Christian.

As I said, the Jews believe that the Messiah would be an angel or a theophany. So when Jesus, being a man, claimed to be the Messiah, they wrongly assumed that Jesus was claiming to be an angel or a theophany.
As I've already stated to you...the above is such nonsense that I will not reply.

Post some scripture...if you can proving what you've stated.
I've asked you this before.

But Jesus wasn't killed because the Jews were righteously enforcing the Law. They acted out of hatred and fear because as they said, they were afraid that he would take away their place. The blaspheme charge was trumped up and false.
Oh. And you think THE ROMANS cared about Jesus being or not being God?
If you remember He did die on a Roman cross.
It's THE JEWS that said Jesus was blaspheming by calling Himself God.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amigo de christo

Lizbeth

Well-Known Member
Jul 22, 2022
4,392
5,843
113
67
Ontario, Canada
Faith
Christian
Country
Canada
You do realize sister . You do realize jus who you are speaking too .
A solider of trumps interfaith . this people has its hopes in the earthen
and the earthen shall all be dissolved and all whose hope was in men along with it .
They see as THEY desire to see sister . Did you know that for all my warnings
NOT A ONE who has went that direction has YET to repent and actaully i have seen some of them getting worse too .
It's so sad brother. Modern Christianity is not the same biblical Christianity that was preached and taught in the early church, or even the church of two or three generations ago from what I can tell.
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
It's so sad brother. Modern Christianity is not the same biblical Christianity that was preached and taught in the early church, or even the church of two or three generations ago from what I can tell.
You are right my dear sister . Modern and post modern christanity IS TANKED .
post modern is worse than modern though it tries to act as though its not .
The best i can tell is what sped this up
was the rick warren seeker friendly purpose driven life and etc .
Churches seemed to grab hold of that years and years ago . THEY grabbed hold
of this HOW to build your church junk . AND that was A BUSINESS MODEL
Thus how did they grow their churches , THEY PANDERED to men . THAT IS HOW they grew them .
And it has went down hill very fast since then .
 

amigo de christo

Well-Known Member
Sep 12, 2020
29,936
50,712
113
53
San angelo
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
It's so sad brother. Modern Christianity is not the same biblical Christianity that was preached and taught in the early church, or even the church of two or three generations ago from what I can tell.
the ecumincal movmenent and rick warren Seeker friendly model
has pretty much just about FINSIHED the CHURCHES OFF
and it has led them to interfaith which both sides preach . That will be their end sister .
You see soon , the decieved within christendom and all the false religons
will come together under what they all believe is LOVE and of GOD . only IT AINT NEITHER .
ITS peaking sister , its peaking right now .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marvelloustime
Status
Not open for further replies.