Ronald Nolette
Well-Known Member
Not really. To prove a doctrine we need to look at many verses.Is it possible to stick to one verse?
Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
Not really. To prove a doctrine we need to look at many verses.Is it possible to stick to one verse?
Romans 9 is Paul explaining why God chose to have mercy on the Israelites.First to reply to verse 41.
There is no "corporate salvation" as you call it. there is only individual salvation. He uses the examples of Jacob and Esau as individuals as well as Pharoah.
The people worshipping the golden calf were a GROUP of persons which were all individual but comprised A GROUP...Verses 1-5 is Israel as a nation. 6-8 transitions to individuals. all the pronouns from that point are are singular. If they were "corporate" they would be plural.
He then poses a rhetorical question from a hypothetical individual.
Paul delcared god will have mercy on whom he will and hardens (all singular) whom he will!
Great. I said Romans 9 was the best you had but it did not fit Christian theology as Paul taught it.9 is very relevant. verses 18-24 are climatic! For he is speaking of individuals both of Jews and gentiles and not nations .
And I did not say that the verse supports YOUR theology. I said if it was the only verse on how people get saved it would lend some support. but I then told you we have to look at all verses on how people come or not come to god.
We will soon see.and of course the verses I posted support the biblical doctrine of election.
Romans 9 is not dismissed due to poor grammar....if you're going to be demeaning...this conversation will soon end, as it does in most cases involving the reformed.1 cor. 2, romans 8 and JOhn 6 verses all show the natural or unsaved man cannot come to God on trheir own, nor do they even want to!
But as you dismiss Romans 9 due to poor grammar, then take these three verses and try to defend free will from them. From
Easy RN. Every verse is easily exegeted because the NT is one entire and complete thought and every verse is reconcilable to every other verse.JOhn 6.
37 All that the Father giveth me shall come to me; and him that cometh to me I will in no wise cast out.
39 And this is the Father's will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day.
44 No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.
You haven't shown me anything yet....but you could try again.the problem with your lone verse is that it is a simple statement of fact or a declaratory statement. what it does not do is explain how or why they resist the Spirit (not grace). the fact your verse declares, as far as the hows and whys have tro be determined in other verses, lijke I showed you.
Agreed. The natural man cannot understand God.An unsaved man can do nothing to please god. turning to Jesus of ones own unsaved human nature is something that pleases God and God said an unsaved person cannot do that.
Also in 1 Cor. 2 the unsaved does not even want to turn to God for the natural mind thinks it is foolishness.
This from a person that will not accept Romans 9???Then one also has to consider the fact that when Stephen said that it was the time of transition from Israel to the church.
Sure there was always a remnant. what does that have anything to do with anything?and your argument for Romans 9 has no merit. Israels hearts were always hardened as Judges through Malachi shows. there was ans always be a remnant.
Ooops. You posted verse 39 and 40.Paul made it clear in romans 3 that no one seeks God! Unless you believe he was in error.
Jesus told th ePharisees:
John 5:39-40
King James Version
39 Search the scriptures; for in them ye think ye have eternal life: and they are they which testify of me.
40 And ye will not come to me, that ye might have life.
I commented on John 6:37, 39 and 44.Why will they not come? John 6:37&39&44. Not some mysterious free will that they decided on their own to not come. John 10:25-27 also bears that out!
YOu complain I write many verses. well I will make my case from Scripture and not philosophy or some kind of reasoining and improper use of a passage.
I agree.Not really. To prove a doctrine we need to look at many verses.
Sorry but that is not true!Romans 9 is Paul explaining why God chose to have mercy on the Israelites.
It's about corporate salvation....and you don't have to put it in quotation marks because it's a REAL theological system that is believed by every single denomination except for the reformed.
I can't spend my time posting about Romans 9 since you will not care about anything I post since you don't even accept the concept which is truth.
The Promise was kept through Jacob,,,not Esau......It should have been kept by the OLDER brother, not the younger.
But, enough of that.
So, they were condemned as individuals, not as a group. the fact they all were condemned was still an individual thing. the only "group thing" in the OT was that all Gentiles were without god and without hope in the Word as Paul said in ephesians 2.The people worshipping the golden calf were a GROUP of persons which were all individual but comprised A GROUP...
this is what CORPORATE means.
I am not reformed.Romans 9 is not dismissed due to poor grammar....if you're going to be demeaning...this conversation will soon end, as it does in most cases involving the reformed.
It does not say that and you know that. You are adding opinion to the verse.John 6:37
When a person becomes saved by faith in God.......
The Father gives that person over to Jesus because Jesus is the Savior who was sent to save the whole world.
This is not the free will that you argue for. Men can make choices here and we can choose or reject things here on earth. I call that volition to differentiate it from free will which is an unsaved mans ability to choose God of His natural nature. Which the bible says He can't.Philemon 1:14
14but without your consent I did not want to do anything, so that your goodness would not be, in effect, by compulsion but of your own free will.
The bible refers to man's free will because man has A FREE WILL.
Once again you mistake simple declaratory statement as an apologetic for unsaVED BEING ABLE TO GO TO GOD OF THEIR FALLEN NATURE. Yes it does say8 they will not come, but it doesn't say why or how they would come. they don't come because jesus said they are not of His sheep, sop they are not given to jesus by the Father nor are they drawn to Jesus by the Father. See the NT explains why this statement is true. they will not because they cannot.Ooops. You posted verse 39 and 40.
In verse 40 Jesus states that THEY WILL NOT GO TO HIM.
Well then you should easily flood me with verses that prove your hypotheses above.Again...this denotes free will.
Free will is all over the NT....can't get away from it RN.
I agree.
So reply to my post to you just now....in the same way that I replied to yours.
I commented on John 6:37, 39 and 44.
Now please reply and exegete the verses I've posted.
Thanks.
i hate to be the bringer of sad and heavy newsI agree.
So reply to my post to you just now....in the same way that I replied to yours.
quaote the two great commandments . the lovely commandments which would have FULLFILLED it all .I agree.
So reply to my post to you just now....in the same way that I replied to yours.
IN ordeer to be drawn, they have to be given to Jesus.
take note one and all , GOD draws one TO CHRIST , not to budda allah and any other dung pile religonThat is Hyper-Calvinism nonsense.
That is the "pre-destined" John Calvinism, "doctrine of devils:" you feel a compulsion to rant.
The reality is.. Jesus said..>>>"If i be lifted up (on the Cross) I will DRAW.... ALL people to myself".
Lying Calvinists, who are mind owned by Calvinism, deny the "ALL" because they are programmed by a devil, named J. Calvin... to only see the words "elect", and "predestined" as if those are the only 2 words and 2 concepts found in the entire NT.
That is their OBSESSION, that is caused by John Calvin's "doctrine of devils".
Its a MIND Trap, and they are LOCKED UP.............The NT refers to this mind blindness as a "strong hold".
Paul says they are "Bewitched" by a "MAN"., and that is why they are obsessed with CALVINISM.
No it is what the bible says as written!That is Hyper-Calvinism nonsense.
That is the "pre-destined" John Calvinism, "doctrine of devils:" you feel a compulsion to rant.
The reality is.. Jesus said..>>>"If i be lifted up (on the Cross) I will DRAW.... ALL people to myself".
Lying Calvinists, who are mind owned by Calvinism, deny the "ALL" because they are programmed by a devil, named J. Calvin... to only see the words "elect", and "predestined" as if those are the only 2 words and 2 concepts found in the entire NT.
That is their OBSESSION, that is caused by John Calvin's "doctrine of devils".
Its a MIND Trap, and they are LOCKED UP.............The NT refers to this mind blindness as a "strong hold".
Paul says they are "Bewitched" by a "MAN"., and that is why they are obsessed with CALVINISM.
The above is all very true RN.No it is what the bible says as written!
37 All that the Father giveth me shall come to me; and him that cometh to me I will in no wise cast out.
39 And this is the Father's will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day.
44 No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.
Romans 8:8
King James Version
8 So then they that are in the flesh cannot please God.
Being bereft of teaching Scripture, you have been reduced to just accusations, slander and ad-hominems.
In over a dozen threads, you have failed to prove one of your false accusations with Scripture. You just use Scripture to try to falsely accuse teh brethren.
No it is what the bible says as written!
37 All that the Father giveth me shall come to me; and him that cometh to me I will in no wise cast out.
39 And this is the Father's will which hath sent me, that of all which he hath given me I should lose nothing, but should raise it up again at the last day.
King James Version8 So then they that are in the flesh cannot please God.
you and this man battle it out like no other . YET i i seeing something you both might be believing .THe bible is spiritually discerned.
So, when you just read it, you get nothing, and that is part of your issue with the scriptures.
THe other part, is that John Calvin has you teaching His Theology, and you believe its "the bible".
That is the deception, that Calvin causes in people, like you.
You are taking the verse out of Context.
The context is verse 40., and i'll show you down below....
40 And this is the will of him that sent me, that EVERY ONE which seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life: and I will raise him up at the last day."""
See the EVERY ONE who Believes?
Notice that Jesus didnt say..>>>>"only the pre-destined"?
Why is that?
Because this is JOHN's Gospel.. and John told you, that "WHOSOEVER Believes".... and that means ALL
EVERY One
This is John 3:16, that explains, the '"every one".. .in your verse.
Yes, and that means when a religious person, is trying to lead Christians to John Calvin, they cannot please God.
Thats you.
You are the SELLER of Calvinism, and that is not Christianity... that is a Disciple of Calvin, obeying His Master. @Ronald Nolette
Not a one of you agrees one bit with my warnings against interfaith
interfaith is not about that my friend . That is a trick . i already know that anyone is welcome to come to a church .My Home Church is not a "denomination".
We are a bible believing Autonomous , Local Assembly of born again Believers.
My Church Membership = is a Messianic Congregation .
So, as far as it being "inter-faith"........Well, we allow everyone to come and join us celebrate Jesus and His Free Gift of Salvation.
We have services that are different then what you find in America, , in most "mainline" Denominations..
WE have more the one speaker, who shares a scriptural message.... we have a lot more of praise and worship.. .. we have a "break time" where members can just bond in love with each other, and celebrate Jesus and have some apple pieces and honey, or Milk and Coffee.
I think the American term is "laid back"... or "Free in Jesus"......is how we allow a service to serve the believer and honor Jesus The Christ.
We dont "watch the clock".. so, when a member or visitor needs to get up and go..then .. its no biggie........come back again soon.
What a church service should feel like is a big happy and holy family reunion, as we are all the Family of God, born again. come together again to give Jesus and The Father our love and devotion.
INTERFAITH is saying flat out , IF you pay attention to its main leaders , that our truth is no better than the truth of them false religoins .
And it doesn't say those who exercise free will either.40 And this is the will of him that sent me, that EVERY ONE which seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life: and I will raise him up at the last day."""
See the EVERY ONE who Believes?
Notice that Jesus didnt say..>>>>"only the pre-destined"?
Why is that?
Because this is JOHN's Gospel.. and John told you, that "WHOSOEVER Believes".... and that means ALL
EVERY One...
= This is John 3:16, that explains, the '"every one".. .in your verse.
There are professional doctors who can help with this intense obsessive thinking patterns you have.THe bible is spiritually discerned.
So, when you just read it, you get nothing, and that is part of your issue with the scriptures.
THe other part, is that John Calvin has you teaching His Theology, and you believe its "the bible".
That is the deception, that Calvin causes in people, like you.
Well now you have proven you fail at knowing Scripture.Yes, and that means when a religious person, is trying to lead Christians to John Calvin, they cannot please God.
Thats you for over 30 yrs, @Ronald Nolette
And it is what all Arminiasts do as well. go to the bible thining they already know.The above is all very true RN.
So you're not a Calvinist?
Or you can't find any verses that SPECIFICALLY state what calvinists believe??
It might be no. 2 because the NT does NOT teach Calvinism.
Will get to your long post ASAP.
PS
This is something all calvinists do.
They quote scripture that ALL Christians believe THINKING that it somehow supports their theology....
but that's only because they come to scripture with a set of beliefs that are nowhere to be found in scripture.
I think it's a good idea to go to the bible and see what it has to teach us.
Not go there thinking we already know what it teaches and post verses that have nothing to do with calvinism.
So are you saying you have no certain knowledge of anything the bible teaches? Or do yopu go to the bible thinking you have already learned things teh bible teaches and you are just hurling a not subtle ad-hominem?I think it's a good idea to go to the bible and see what it has to teach us.
Not go there thinking we already know what it teaches and post verses that have nothing to do with calvinism.
And it doesn't say those who exercise free will either.
I believe in these passages 100% but they do not say how or by what means any one believes.
YOu rproblem is you have been so indoctrinated in Armenian theology
Any other verses you have misinterpreted you like to bring forward to prove your false hypotheis that the 5 points are wrong?
There are professional doctors who can help with this intense obsessive thinking patterns you have.
you have been fat fingering the key board my friend . I do that often myself .So are you saying you have no certain knowledge of anything the bible teaches? Or do yopu go to the bible thinking you have already learned things teh bible teaches and you are just hurling a not subtle ad-hominem?
If you are not sure you know anything with any certainty with whatr the bible teaches please tewll me. for then this is a futile discussion for you can't even be sure you know what you think you know!