Let me start with a story. I'll be changing the real names for confidentiality issues.
James Jr was 30 when his mother told him that James Sr, the man who he had always thought to be his father was not his biological father. His biological father was Dr Taylor, the family doctor. Dr Taylor was a friend of the family for years, and actually James always felt a vague affective affinity to that man. Along with such news, James learnt that he had half-brothers (those of Dr Taylor with his wife).
Instead of finding out the evidence or details that support his mom's revelation, James started thinking "My mom is most likely referring to another James Sr and to another Dr Taylor, since James Sr is my dad, and Dr Taylor is the family doctor".
This thread is for you to rehearse apologetics regarding the idea that is getting somewhat popular in the Internet, that Allah is not the God who Jews and Christians worship, and that the Jesus that Jehovah Witnesses follow as their Savior is not the Jesus that Christianity follows as their Savior.
- In regard to Allah, this thread is NOT to point out to the differences we all know between Islam and Judaism or Christianism, but to discuss why these differences should/should not make us consider Allah as "another God".
- In regard to the JW, this thread is NOT to argue in favor or against the deity of Jesus, since such topic is not permitted by the rules of the Forum. The point is to discuss why, regardless of the opinion JW and Christians have about His metaphysical nature/origin, such Jesus should / should not be considered "another Jesus".
As a starting point, my thesis is that Allah is the same God worshipped by Jews and Christians, and Jesus is the same Jesus followed by JW and the rest of Christians. What is different is the discourse these groups have about God or Jesus, in aspects that are not essential for worship or salvation.
The importance or recognizing this is that it enables us to speak about God with Muslims, and about Jesus with Jehovah Witnesses, on the shared assumption that we are interested in worshipping the same God and following the same Jesus.
Going back to my story, I found absurd for James Jr to think that his mother was referring to "another James Sr" or "another Dr Taylor", even if the information James Jr has got represents a major change in how he will perceive those two men.