Timtofly
Well-Known Member
Only after being caught up. Why are you adamant one has to happen prior to the other?The mystery is that not all of us will die, but our bodies will all be changed to be incorruptible and immortal at the last trumpet.
The mystery is that the soul is caught up out of one physical body, and placed into another physical body in the air. There have never been naked souls in the air. The only thing ever seen in the air was a physical body.
Show me one verse that was not symbolic that describes literal souls moving through the air. No one in the NT was a witness to the OT bodily ascending with Jesus into Paradise. But to say it did not happen, is ridiculous. It was a mystery still, because all the first century church had to go on was that souls waited in sheol until the final resurrection. So people physically coming with Jesus from Paradise at the Second Coming is still a mystery to you, because you deny they have physical bodies.
You want many to assume a rapture in Revelation 19, but that is just an assumption as much as in any other chapter in Revelation, no?
The only time a person is brought back to life and physically ascends into heaven is in Revelation 11:11-12. And many interpretations wrongly apply that as happening at the 6th Trumpet. Revelation 19 is not the 6th Trumpet, by any stretch of interpretation. Revelation 11:11-12 is not the mystery that Paul is talking about, because the 2 witnesses are not alive and remain. They had been killed 3.5 days earlier. Are you saying a percentage of their body remained alive and that covers your eschatological bias?
The word saint does not mean church. Saint could mean elect, but their redemption has not been finalized. The elect are in Jesus Christ, because they are souls under the alter (symbolic, not literal), named in the Lamb's book of life (literal, not symbolic). But those beheaded found in Revelation 20:4 are not even redeemed until after they stand as literal souls on earth, before thrones and judged. The setting is on earth, because Satan was on the earth when bound. These souls were never in heaven. You don't even allow them to have a physical body after they are judged. These souls do not represent humans before nor during your alleged first century millennium that stops at the Second Coming. These souls were beheaded during the short time given to Satan, prior to Satan being bound. Explain how there were beheaded souls judged in the first century, then you use that as souls without bodies in heaven. How were there souls both in heaven and sheol, prior to the Cross? Paul never says souls are constantly judged year after year until the Second Coming. Only once does Paul say that all must stand before the judgment seat of Christ, not to be given eternal life, but to be judged and rewarded according to works burned up or works that remain. That has nothing to do with being given a physical body. Where would you place the rapture in 2 Corinthians 5?
You want straightforward? That would be that many were beheaded just prior to Armageddon. Then Satan was defeated at Armageddon, and bound for a thousand years. Then those souls just beheaded were judged, and the result of that judgement was the ability to live on the earth for a thousand years while Satan was bound. That is straightforward. Now to just slap "church" on everything is not straightforward. The term ecclesia means a called out assembly, not just every one in history. A saint could be part of the church or not. Elijah was a saint, but not a called out assembly of humans. Noah and his family were assumed a called out assembly, as they restarted earth's population called out of the wickedness that was destroyed. They would also be saints first, then called out, no? The church of Moses in the wilderness was called out of Egypt. Abraham and company were called out of Ur. The NT church was called out of the world, and set apart by submission to the Holy Spirit. Those beheaded were not called out. They chopped their heads off, to remain saints and part of the elect named in the Lamb's book of life. They escaped the second death, but they had to stand in judgment, before they could be redeemed. The church does not have to stand in judgment before thrones and judged to receive the second birth. While church does include saints. Saints does not necessarily mean all have been made part of the church.
You seem to overlook that the second birth is not given at conception. The second birth is a conscious decision to stop living for one's self, and submit to the Holy Spirit. So being called out is not from birth, but individuals choosing to obey the call of being called out. You want to say these beheaded were not actually beheaded, but symbolic of leaving the old life behind and spiritually submitting to the Holy Spirit. There is no indication that being beheaded is symbolic of anything else, but literally chopping one's head off. In fact you agree they are only souls, because they left the physical body when the head was chopped off. You cannot have it both ways. Were they physically killed in the first century prior to the church being called out, ie your millennium? Or were they physically killed in the time frame of the second coming?
If they were never physically killed, but just symbolize Jews around the time Jesus was born, how can they be the church during your millennium? How did the disciples who started the church symbolically stand before thrones and judged? Explain what the thrones symbolize in first century context.