Good morning, Aunty Jane:
And greetings to you also….
Thanks for such a comprehensive response. I appreciate your time and clarity, which is important not only for me but for all our potential readers.
I fully agree with your view on miracles.
If God and the devil had to compete for miracles, the confusion would be worse than it is now…..
Ceasing the miracles once Christianity had been established, meant that only the devil was engaging in them…yet only serious Bible students (which we are all encouraged to be) would be able to discern this fact, whilst others would agonize over why some are cured of their illnesses while others are not.
Some faith healers are nothing but showmen and if their so called healing doesn’t work, they blame the person for not having enough faith…..that never happened in the first century. On one occasion I can recall, it was the ones performing the miracles who lacked faith, and failed…..not the receiver.
Thanks for being candid. My invitation for you is to let God help you to develop gradually more compassion for all people.
Continue to be firm against superstition, but more compassionate with those who follow superstitions.
I have the same kind of compassion for people as Jesus did….he offered his truth to all but never once chased after anyone pleading with them to listen to him…or else. He allowed all with free will to process what he said and to adjust their thinking accordingly.
If you remember the occasion when he spoke of ‘eating his flesh and drinking his blood’, his Jewish audience were appalled! And many walked away saying that his speech was shocking…..Jesus waited, and asked his apostles ‘are you going to walk away too?’ Their response was….’whom shall we go away to? You have sayings of everlasting life’. So he explained to them that his sayings were “spirit and life”….meaning that they were not to be taken literally. What about those who walked away? They never waited for the explanation…..he did not chase after them.
In the same way that Simon (the man who wanted to "buy" with money the gift of God) asked the apostle to pray for him, because he felt unworthy and scared, some Catholics pray to other people who think are holier or in a better position to take their prayers to God.
This assumes that these “saints” (including Mary) were alive somewhere to make these intercessions for them. They prayed TO these saints to intercede on their behalf….and yet the Bible clearly states that 1) Jesus is our only mediator…and 2) there is no immortal soul that lives on after death….and that the resurrection of the “saints” (holy ones) would not take place until Christ’s return.
1 Thess 4:15-17…
“For this is what we tell you by Jehovah’s word, that we the living who survive to the presence of the Lord will in no way precede those who have fallen asleep in death; 16 because the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a commanding call, with an archangel’s voice and with God’s trumpet, and those who are dead in union with Christ will rise first. 17 Afterward we the living who are surviving will, together with them, be caught away in clouds to meet the Lord in the air; and thus we will always be with the Lord.”
So for most of the time that the Catholic church was praying to these saints they were “sleeping” in their graves, awaiting their resurrection….ready to take up their positions as “kings and priests” in the heavenly kingdom. (Rev 20:6) They were praying to dead people, whereas Christ is alive forever.
We have to “know” God and his son (John 17:3) the way the Bible teaches about them.
We have to know what a “soul” is in the Bible, and what it means in both Hebrew and Greek. (Ezek 18:4) It never means a disembodied spirit.
In Genesis, all living creatures are called “souls”. There is no such thing as an immortal soul…..what makes a soul a soul, is the breath in its lungs. Like Adam, who “became a living soul” when God started him breathing. (Gen 2:7) We have no superiority to animals in death. (Eccl 3:19-20) We all end up in the same place.
So Christendom’s beliefs hinge on three things that Jesus never taught….the triune nature of God….the existence of an immortal soul…and heaven or hell as opposite destinations for the souls of man.
Since Jesus is Perfect (and for Catholics, He is God) they feel also unworthy in coming directly to Jesus. Popular saints seem more earth-grounded, closer to their experience. Should they abandon that practice? Yes, for sure. But that will take further spiritual discernment. For the time being, we have no reason to feel less compassion to them that the compassion we ask God to have for us.
This is the reason why Jesus sent his disciples out to preach…..to present Christ’s message to those who would want to know….many in the first century didn’t want to know….many in this century don’t want to know either…and for the same reasons. They are happy with what they want to believe. God will leave them to their delusions. (2 Thess 2:9-12) They will find out soon enough that their many religions were just a sad substitute for the real one. (Matt 7:21-23)
The Jews of Jesus’ day thought he was an apostate fake Messiah and consented to his murder. Did they think for one moment that they were putting “the son of God” to death? (Matt 27:25)
Their religious leaders had convinced them that he was a worthless trouble maker…..and in putting him to death, they would quash any further development….but as Gamaliel, a leader in the Sanhedrin said, when he spoke to the religious leaders who wanted to persecute the Christians….citing other examples of false messiahs he said….
”I say to you, do not meddle with these men, but let them alone. For if this scheme or this work is from men, it will be overthrown; 39 but if it is from God, you will not be able to overthrow them. Otherwise, you may even be found fighters against God himself.” (Acts 5:34-39)
What does history show? Despite warning of an apostasy in Christianity just as that occurred in Judaism, Christendom continues to expand into a ridiculously vast array of sects……as I like to say…it’s like trying to find a diamond in a pile of broken glass…….only God can lead us to the diamond….(John 6:44, 65)
Can you see why questions such as presented in this thread, pale into insignificance when compared to the very foundational beliefs held by the majority? Jesus plainly said that it won’t be the majority who are saved…(Matt 7:13-14)
The very reason why we are to be preachers is to offer God’s truth in the same way as Jesus taught his first century disciples. (Matt 10:11-14) It is offered, but not forced. We choose what to believe.