DrBubbaLove
New Member
- Jan 17, 2008
- 383
- 2
- 0
- 63
Learn something new every day. So if nothing else this exercise should serve to better understand one's own view and also understand the view of someone opposed. Knew the Church taught that ALL will rise to judgement (with a body) and that the damned go to Hell body and soul. Did not know and never thought to ask what happens to the damned before judgement. As the Church has the saved going to Heaven (most through Purgatory), just found out the damned go straight to Hell (just a soul) immediately upon death and remain there until judgement when they are raised along with everyone else. So even their knee will be made to bow, as part of 'every'.Anyway, Jesus says "And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell. " which indicates both body and soul are in hell. The opposing view will correctly note the word "destroy" here (while perhaps taking a pass on why there is a body too). We simply note that the word kill or death was not used. So what could destroy mean?Our view handles that as has been mentioned earlier. Death obviously does not mean an end to what is a human in the first case, but in this verse it is not even used a second time. Destruction could indicate, as has been posted earlier, a no going back, an end to an existence that could be recognize as human. That existence is destroyed and what remains, is only that which once was a human. Fire destroys a tree, but there still remains something which was formerly a tree, mostly ashes. The soul of a man is an immortal spirit and apparently our resurrected bodies are immortal as well. But just looking at the soul, God creates it immortal. It is a part of what we are from before our birth. So only God could undo what He has made immortal. Which means if we say a soul is annihilated, then it has to be God DOING it and not some other created force. So even if we want the damned in Hell eventually annihilated, it would have to be God doing the annihilation, not any power of Hell. This we cannot abide. We also say Hell severs no purpose. Only good can serve a purpose and Hell is certainly not good. Hell is the absence of all good, which is Evil. Evil attacks purpose. Purpose also supposes time in order for the purpose to be achieved. Heaven and Hell are concepts that appear outside of time. What sense would it make to raise all the dead with new bodies only to throw the damned body and soul into Hell? Why not just leave them as spirits since their original bodies are already gone? Can understand now why some came up with the idea of soul sleep, as it would be necessary in some other views of the afterlife.