An Appeal for Free Speech

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Aunty Jane

Well-Known Member
Sep 16, 2021
7,002
3,836
113
Sydney
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
In response to having a post deleted as per ‘newer’ forum rules, FWIW, can we please have some equality on the issue of the trinity? Apparently it cannot be discussed either for or against this very controversial doctrine, yet many posts are still appearing on this topic and only one group is being gagged as far as I can see.

Is it a “choice of words” issue? Is it “only certain words or phrases” that are not allowed?

There are no rules about debating it in a pm with one another xx
Hi Rita, a debate with no audience is not a debate, and negates the basis for having one.

If people are not equipped with the truth, and what the Bible says about both sides of this doctrine, how are they ever going to be able to defend their faith? Both sides claim to be “Christians” and should defend their position in a Christian manner. I do not see that as asking too much. No one has anything to fear from the truth. And no one can come to Christ unless they have the Father’s permission. (John 6:65)

The problem as I see it, and it is very evident, is that some people lose their civility and behave badly when their beliefs are challenged….wasn’t this the case also in Jesus’ day? The Pharisees had the majority of the people under the impression that what they taught was the truth, and what Jesus taught was heresy…..and what they attempted to do to Jesus and his disciples, was to silence them. Are we not grateful that they did not succeed? Those who wanted to hear Jesus teach, chose to do so….and those who opposed him, chose not to….and we saw that their hatred festered into murder. (Matt 27:25)

Gamaliel’s speech to his fellow Jewish leaders, who were intent on ridding themselves of these opposers, rings as true today as it did back then….

Acts 5:38-39….
”So under the present circumstances, I say to you, do not meddle with these men, but let them alone. For if this scheme or this work is from men, it will be overthrown; 39 but if it is from God, you will not be able to overthrow them. Otherwise, you may even be found fighters against God himself.”

Wise words……not leaving God out of the situation. Didn’t Jesus promise that no one would ‘snatch his disciples out of his hand’? (John 10:28-29) Where is that faith demonstrated in a place where censorship does not allow freedom of speech because some cannot control their anger?

We have the “ignore” button so that those who choose not to see what we write, don’t have to….but it’s everyone’s choice and their right to see opposing arguments. Why is that choice taken away?

Wouldn’t it be better to ban those who exhibit no self-control and who behave in an unchristian manner, rather than to gag those who simply want to tell the other side of the story, with scriptural support, and with civility?

The great thing about this site is that it is not simply an ‘echo chamber’, which is why most of us are here….freedom of speech is dying in this world, so please don’t let this site die with it.
I believe that is the reason why many sites end up closing down, because free speech is stifled and people look for a site where they can express themselves without censorship. The good thing about having an Unorthodox Forum is that people can choose to go there….or stay away. Place a warning at the entrance and penalize those who offend the rules, as well as each other. Requiring Christian behavior is then the objective.

I understand the problem, but can we appeal this? At least allow us one place to speak freely, and ban those who cannot behave in a Christian manner, and who turn their posts into personal attacks.…and please know how much we appreciate your efforts to stop the rot….just do it fairly, is all we ask…..
 
  • Like
Reactions: amadeus

PS95

Well-Known Member
Jun 16, 2024
1,020
632
113
Eastern Shore
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
In response to having a post deleted as per ‘newer’ forum rules, FWIW, can we please have some equality on the issue of the trinity? Apparently it cannot be discussed either for or against this very controversial doctrine, yet many posts are still appearing on this topic and only one group is being gagged as far as I can see.

Is it a “choice of words” issue? Is it “only certain words or phrases” that are not allowed?


Hi Rita, a debate with no audience is not a debate, and negates the basis for having one.

If people are not equipped with the truth, and what the Bible says about both sides of this doctrine, how are they ever going to be able to defend their faith? Both sides claim to be “Christians” and should defend their position in a Christian manner. I do not see that as asking too much. No one has anything to fear from the truth. And no one can come to Christ unless they have the Father’s permission. (John 6:65)

The problem as I see it, and it is very evident, is that some people lose their civility and behave badly when their beliefs are challenged….wasn’t this the case also in Jesus’ day? The Pharisees had the majority of the people under the impression that what they taught was the truth, and what Jesus taught was heresy…..and what they attempted to do to Jesus and his disciples, was to silence them. Are we not grateful that they did not succeed? Those who wanted to hear Jesus teach, chose to do so….and those who opposed him, chose not to….and we saw that their hatred festered into murder. (Matt 27:25)

Gamaliel’s speech to his fellow Jewish leaders, who were intent on ridding themselves of these opposers, rings as true today as it did back then….

Acts 5:38-39….
”So under the present circumstances, I say to you, do not meddle with these men, but let them alone. For if this scheme or this work is from men, it will be overthrown; 39 but if it is from God, you will not be able to overthrow them. Otherwise, you may even be found fighters against God himself.”

Wise words……not leaving God out of the situation. Didn’t Jesus promise that no one would ‘snatch his disciples out of his hand’? (John 10:28-29) Where is that faith demonstrated in a place where censorship does not allow freedom of speech because some cannot control their anger?

We have the “ignore” button so that those who choose not to see what we write, don’t have to….but it’s everyone’s choice and their right to see opposing arguments. Why is that choice taken away?

Wouldn’t it be better to ban those who exhibit no self-control and who behave in an unchristian manner, rather than to gag those who simply want to tell the other side of the story, with scriptural support, and with civility?

The great thing about this site is that it is not simply an ‘echo chamber’, which is why most of us are here….freedom of speech is dying in this world, so please don’t let this site die with it.
I believe that is the reason why many sites end up closing down, because free speech is stifled and people look for a site where they can express themselves without censorship. The good thing about having an Unorthodox Forum is that people can choose to go there….or stay away. Place a warning at the entrance and penalize those who offend the rules, as well as each other. Requiring Christian behavior is then the objective.

I understand the problem, but can we appeal this? At least allow us one place to speak freely, and ban those who cannot behave in a Christian manner, and who turn their posts into personal attacks.…and please know how much we appreciate your efforts to stop the rot….just do it fairly, is all we ask…..
Hello Jane,
It's not a free speech issue.
It's called a policy. And one that you repeatedly ignore.
It is for the good of the forum for a little bit of peace and less regurgitation of the dead horse kicking.
It aggravates you to no end that we worship and exalt Jesus to the glory of God our Father. It is a Christian forum after all.
We wont stop that and especially to entertain the Jw PET issue- that is used primarily to divert topics.
Jws teach that Christians are, "so-called Christians"-- who worship Satan.

Please for once-Take your pointed finger at these people, and point it towards the mirror. Uneven scales are hated by God.
---WHERE DOES THE BIBLE SAY any of this below ?

"Impersonal life-force of Michael was implanted into Mary's womb" so Michael went out of existence- Jesus then came into existence-.He wasn't the Lord or Christ then just, a perfect human named, Jesus. Then, Jesus died, so that "life force" went back to heaven, so God re-created Michael with it. The man, Jesus is dead forever.. and his body was dissolved likely burned into gases
And you have the gall to despise the trinity? I have all documentation for that above so don't lie to these people.

I don't even know why you call yourself a Christian on here?
How can a Christian be a person who believes and teachers others that you and they are
NOT a child of God,
Not in the new covenant
Not a part of the body of Christ
Do not cry out, ABBA, Father
Not born again,
Not and heir,
Jesus is not your mediator,
Jesus did not die for your sins
NOT declared righteous
Not baptizes into Jesus' death
Not freed from being slaves to sin
Not branches of the true vine
Not partakers of His communion
Not united with Jesus in the likeness of His death ETC ETC

You have all of that ( and more) in common with Unbelievers. That describes an unbeliever perfectly.
Tell us again why we should read anything you write let alone -- on the the deity of Christ?

Again, free speech is not the issue. Do JWs even allow ME or any Christian on their boards at all? NO. it's a policy.
 

lforrest

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Admin
Aug 10, 2012
6,064
7,465
113
Faith
Christian
Please see the statement of faith. Christianity Board Statement of Faith
We are steering the site in a direction that assumes all Christian members agree with some central tenants of the faith. And these are the minimum standard we are now setting for the site. For those who disagree with the statement of faith we leave the option of remaining silent on those issues or changing to other faith members.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rita

Rita

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Dec 20, 2020
4,579
7,993
113
66
South
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
In response to having a post deleted as per ‘newer’ forum rules, FWIW, can we please have some equality on the issue of the trinity? Apparently it cannot be discussed either for or against this very controversial doctrine, yet many posts are still appearing on this topic and only one group is being gagged as far as I can see.

Is it a “choice of words” issue? Is it “only certain words or phrases” that are not allowed?


Hi Rita, a debate with no audience is not a debate, and negates the basis for having one.
Hi Aunty Jane
Just to address the confusion. The trinity can be talked about, it is however a close handed subject , which means it cannot be argued against. This is a Trinity believing forum.
You can debate publicly or privately, it’s still a debate. I was merely offering an alternative for a member to carry on the discussion they were having. ( perhaps I should have used ‘ discussion ‘ instead of ‘ debate ‘ ) Also many members can be added to a pm conversation.
I don’t intend to discuss the policy , it’s been in place since feb and as a mod I don’t have the power to change it anyway. Each member can either choose to accept the policies or not, no one forces anyone to stay here.
 

amadeus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2008
23,233
33,176
113
81
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
In response to having a post deleted as per ‘newer’ forum rules, FWIW, can we please have some equality on the issue of the trinity? Apparently it cannot be discussed either for or against this very controversial doctrine, yet many posts are still appearing on this topic and only one group is being gagged as far as I can see.

Is it a “choice of words” issue? Is it “only certain words or phrases” that are not allowed?


Hi Rita, a debate with no audience is not a debate, and negates the basis for having one.

If people are not equipped with the truth, and what the Bible says about both sides of this doctrine, how are they ever going to be able to defend their faith? Both sides claim to be “Christians” and should defend their position in a Christian manner. I do not see that as asking too much. No one has anything to fear from the truth. And no one can come to Christ unless they have the Father’s permission. (John 6:65)

The problem as I see it, and it is very evident, is that some people lose their civility and behave badly when their beliefs are challenged….wasn’t this the case also in Jesus’ day? The Pharisees had the majority of the people under the impression that what they taught was the truth, and what Jesus taught was heresy…..and what they attempted to do to Jesus and his disciples, was to silence them. Are we not grateful that they did not succeed? Those who wanted to hear Jesus teach, chose to do so….and those who opposed him, chose not to….and we saw that their hatred festered into murder. (Matt 27:25)

Gamaliel’s speech to his fellow Jewish leaders, who were intent on ridding themselves of these opposers, rings as true today as it did back then….

Acts 5:38-39….
”So under the present circumstances, I say to you, do not meddle with these men, but let them alone. For if this scheme or this work is from men, it will be overthrown; 39 but if it is from God, you will not be able to overthrow them. Otherwise, you may even be found fighters against God himself.”

Wise words……not leaving God out of the situation. Didn’t Jesus promise that no one would ‘snatch his disciples out of his hand’? (John 10:28-29) Where is that faith demonstrated in a place where censorship does not allow freedom of speech because some cannot control their anger?

We have the “ignore” button so that those who choose not to see what we write, don’t have to….but it’s everyone’s choice and their right to see opposing arguments. Why is that choice taken away?

Wouldn’t it be better to ban those who exhibit no self-control and who behave in an unchristian manner, rather than to gag those who simply want to tell the other side of the story, with scriptural support, and with civility?

The great thing about this site is that it is not simply an ‘echo chamber’, which is why most of us are here….freedom of speech is dying in this world, so please don’t let this site die with it.
I believe that is the reason why many sites end up closing down, because free speech is stifled and people look for a site where they can express themselves without censorship. The good thing about having an Unorthodox Forum is that people can choose to go there….or stay away. Place a warning at the entrance and penalize those who offend the rules, as well as each other. Requiring Christian behavior is then the objective.

I understand the problem, but can we appeal this? At least allow us one place to speak freely, and ban those who cannot behave in a Christian manner, and who turn their posts into personal attacks.…and please know how much we appreciate your efforts to stop the rot….just do it fairly, is all we ask…..
I agree with you on this, but unfortunately, the powers that be are certain that their stand is so right that even discussion or debate against it cannot be allowed.
 

amadeus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2008
23,233
33,176
113
81
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Please see the statement of faith. Christianity Board Statement of Faith
We are steering the site in a direction that assumes all Christian members agree with some central tenants of the faith. And these are the minimum standard we are now setting for the site. For those who disagree with the statement of faith we leave the option of remaining silent on those issues or changing to other faith members.
Silence then...!
To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven: Ecc 3:1
...a time to keep silence, and a time to speak; Ecc 3:7
 

amadeus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2008
23,233
33,176
113
81
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
...
Just to address the confusion. The trinity can be talked about, it is however a close handed subject , which means it cannot be argued against. This is a Trinity believing forum.
But since quite a few members cannot see or embrace a Trinity, the belief is far from unanimous.
 

shepherdsword

Active Member
Feb 12, 2009
290
217
43
Millington
www.grex.org
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I think debating the Trinity and the deity of Christ is perfectly fine. In the non-Christian forums. Both of those doctrines are essentials to the Christian faith. Belief in them should be a requirement for a Christian tag
 

Rita

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Dec 20, 2020
4,579
7,993
113
66
South
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
But since quite a few members cannot see or embrace a Trinity, the belief is far from unanimous.
It’s always been part of the statement of faith , so when anyone joins and reads it they either know they will agree or not, after that they make the choice to join. Many churches won’t allow membership unless the SOF is agreed upon. We allow many discussions on many things with differing views, and many forums ban discussing the trinity totally. We did try this - it doesn’t matter what we do as we never please everyone and always get criticism.
 
Last edited:

PS95

Well-Known Member
Jun 16, 2024
1,020
632
113
Eastern Shore
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
:no reply: And there it is. :noyyd…..I rest my case.

Not permitted a response…..:hmhehm
Now now, you were too impatient, Auntie.
It was a Christian holiday after all.
The resurrection of Jesus Christ which Jw's deny.
I was so grateful that my JW mom did not deny the bodily resurrection of the Lord, although she was afraid to admit it to the elders because she would have been dis-fellowshipped and shunned and called an apostate.