FHII
Well-Known Member
- Apr 9, 2011
- 4,833
- 2,500
- 113
- Faith
- Christian
- Country
- United States
I understand that Backlit.... I just wanted to make the point.My comment wasn't intended to be denigrating. Just a matter of fact.
Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
I understand that Backlit.... I just wanted to make the point.My comment wasn't intended to be denigrating. Just a matter of fact.
And not withstanding my previous comments regarding ORU, it would be difficult to reject outright the possibility of bias.Ok, well first off I am dealing with a press article and not a study directly. As a scientist, I should not make a comment without reading the research first. More on that shortly.
But there is already a problem in that the title is misleading: its talking about speaking in tongues but the article itself says praying or speaking in tongues. This is a red flag to scientists with integrity.
Second thing is there is no reference given to the study in this post. Perhaps its only a partial quote of a longer article, but if you don't reference it... A scientist won't even bother with it.
I did dig deeper and found a study that delt with such, though I am not sure its the same article or one that simply deals with the same topic.
The world of science is harsh. If you publish something it must be refereed (scrutinized) before being accepted. The journal I looked at seemed to be legit, but may not be accepted by mainstream psychological people.
As a person, I will give Dr. Peterson the benefit of the doubt, but the scientists of the world won't! He is a MD, but they won't care. Thwy will judge him on his methods.
By the way, this Doctor has some skeletons in gia closet. I can overlook them, and science should too... But despite their mask, scientists are human too. They are just hypocrites about it, for the most part.
Even so, I did find a study and briefly read it. It would take me 12 hours or more to do a critical analysis on it. I would have to look at the testing methods first. It appears they mentioned hormone levels.
Well, the research question woul be if this data is different to merely relaxing in your easy chair with a beer, or having sex, or listening to classical music, or praying to Allah, or.... You get my point.
As I sit here, I got a kitty on my lap and its comforting! So... Is speaking in tongues any different from the activities I mentioned? If the data is the same, a scientist will conclude that praying or speaking in tongues is no more effective than good sex or petting a kitty!
Now, that is the scientist in me... I'm just relating the method and reasoning.
Yeah... Bias. Its something that scientists reject. With Science data is supposed to be indisputable. So when you talk to a scientist about his or her data and even suggest a bias, they will be offended! But go talk to a rival scientist and see what happens!And not withstanding my previous comments regarding ORU, it would be difficult to reject outright the possibility of bias.
Interesting... I have a few suspicions.
In my formal education I have been schooled in the methods of science. Scientific studies and theories are... Well, messy. If you are an academic scientist you understand. I am not purposely trying to discredit this study, but I am letting you know how science works.
I looked into this and its questionable that speaking in tongues is the main point over prayer. I couldnt spend alot of time on it as it was on my lunch break. If there is interest, I will look deeper as a scientist and give my perspective.
Overall, I do believe prayer has a positive psychological effect. Proper "unknown tongues" included. So I do find this study interesting.
Even so my friend. Back in 1976 my wife and I as very nominal and minimal Catholics attended some Pentecostal revival meetings together. She began speaking in an unknown tongue the 3rd night. For me it was 6 weeks later. The difference was that I was not ready to give up what was necessary to give up in my repentance.
That was again as you say only the beginning for both of us. We had a lot of growing to do. We had many more experiences to go through...
Not then... not even for a while, but the gift of dancing would be mine and eventually I would dance before the Lord even in the spaces between those pews. What a mighty God we serve!The look on your face when you realize why the area between the pews are larger at a Holy Ghost Church.
![]()
A friend sent this to me.
Hello. Is there a reason you decided to bless me with such a greeting? A simple "hi there" without any thought, opinion or opposition to my writing following it?Hi there
HA HA Just Hi!Hello. Is there a reason you decided to bless me with such a greeting? A simple "hi there" without any thought, opinion or opposition to my writing following it?
it is reading stuff like that which inhibited me from using my God-given gift.I personally believe babbling gibberish in unknown language is spiritually dangerous.
I believe that "tongues" of Acts was really more like modern interpreters on TV. I was guided to this by Renton MachLachan's book 'Tongues Revisited' and some other articles, as well as also my own experience & study/research.
Bible says when speaking tongues in public if there is no one to interpret the tongues they should be silent. Otherwise it leads to confusion like the Tower of Babel.
I personally believe babbling gibberish in unknown language is spiritually dangerous.
You must get past men who do that, even though they may sincerely believe they are working for God. Really, however, I believe that they are as in for the Left hand of God.it is reading stuff like that which inhibited me from using my God-given gift.
I take no notice of them anymore amadeus. I listen to God and trust him to guide me.You must get past men who do that, even though they may sincerely believe they are working for God. Really, however, I believe that they are as in for the Left hand of God.
Pharaoh was working as the Left hand of God when Moses was asking to the man let God's people go.
Amen sister! Give God the glory!I take no notice of them anymore amadeus. I listen to God and trust him to guide me.
Good to know. And I hope you don't get put off by some of the stuff unbelievers post on here like I did. But I have repented of it and started to use the gift again.I believe in speaking in tongues and do it often. It has been a tremendous help in my prayer life, which then effects all my life.
Until unbelievers have their blinders removed,... i love debating w/ unbelievers and believers, hoping to inspire a love for the truth.Good to know. And I hope you don't get put off by some of the stuff unbelievers post on here like I did. But I have repented of it and started to use the gift again.
The ones I am talking about don't 'debate' but just condemn anything that they disagree with.Until unbelievers have their blinders removed,... i love debating w/ unbelievers and believers, hoping to inspire a love for the truth.