How does Calvin interpret these passages? It’s difficult to determine, because he did not comment on them in the
Institutes (except for one veiled, ambiguous reference above), and did not write a commentary on Revelation. So we will have to examine how other Protestants deal with this fascinating biblical data. Methodists Adam Clarke and John Wesley in their commentaries simply make the prayers presented in 5:8 figurative. Clarke makes a rather curious assertion concerning Revelation 8:3-4:
"It is not said that the angel presents these prayers. He presents the incense, and the prayers ascend with it."
But the incense is the prayers of the saints in Revelation 5:8, making Clarke’s contention implausible. Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown do some eisegesis of their own in commenting on 8:3-4 (capitalization in original):
"How precisely their ministry, in perfuming the prayers of the saints and offering them on the altar of incense, is exercised, we know not, but we do know they are not to be prayed TO . . . It is not the saints who give the angel the incense; nor are their prayers identified with the incense; nor do they offer their prayers to him. Christ alone is the Mediator through whom, and to whom, prayer is to be offered."
How, indeed, do we know the angels are not asked to intercede? For it stands to reason that they would be offering the prayers of the saints only if they were asked to – otherwise those prayers would not be, in a sense, theirs to offer.
Taken flatly denies this.
Lastly, the fact that Christ is mediator is not questioned by anyone. Asking a saint in heaven to pray for us no more interferes with the unique mediation of Christ than does asking a person on earth to pray for us.
We always pray in Christ, through His power, and to Him, whether it is directly to Him, or by means of another person or angel, in heaven or on earth.
This is too much for Taken to comprehend.
The (false) dichotomy between Christ’s mediation and human or angelic mediation need not be drawn at all; it arises only because of the Protestant’s
needless alarmism at God’s making use of creatures to fulfill his purposes. Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown’s comment on Revelation 5:8 exhibits even more of a sort of “fortress mentality”:
This gives not the least sanction to Rome’s dogma of our praying to saints. Though they be employed by God in some way unknown to us to present our prayers (nothing is said of their interceding for us), yet we are told to pray only to Him (Rev. 19:10; 22:8, 9).
We are not told in Scripture that we cannot ask someone in heaven to pray for us. Saints in heaven are more alive and aware and far more holy than we are. They watch us (Heb. 12:1). They are aware of earthly happenings (Rev. 6:9-10). They can certainly be given extraordinary capacities for knowledge by God; there is nothing implausible or intrinsically impossible or unbiblical in that notion at all.
St. Paul states about the afterlife in heaven:
1 Corinthians 13:12 For now we see in a mirror dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall understand fully, even as I have been fully understood.
Therefore, they can pray for us and we can ask for their prayers. We know that they can come back to earth (from the four examples given earlier). Are we to believe that when such saints come to earth they can pray, but immediately upon returning to heaven they cannot once again? And if they can present our prayers, why is it so inconceivable that they could intercede for us?
Albert Barnes in his comment on both Revelation 5:8 and 8:3 draws some hairsplitting distinctions that would make the most skillful lawyer envious:
Abraham / rich man…Their Body’s were DEAD.
Living souls depart out of Dead body’s.
Two departed living souls…can communicate.
So the rich man is not seeking Abraham's intercession? Obviously, being dead does not disqualify a person from interceding. And neither does being alive on earth.
Was the dead rich man asking Abraham a question…yes…so?
Was the dead rich man praising Abraham? No…
Worshiping Abraham? No.
Thanking Abraham? No.
Asking Abraham for help for his errant brothers on earth,
yes, that you deny. Such prayers only counts if a person is not dead? That's not in the Bible, as I have shown. .
You think every time you ask someone a question you are “Spiritually PRAYING” to them?
Another headless chicken comment. I ask you questions and you instantly become deaf
.
How does Calvin interpret these passages? It’s difficult to determine, because he did not comment on them in the
Institutes (except for one veiled, ambiguous reference above), and did not write a commentary on Revelation. So we will have to examine how other Protestants deal with this fascinating biblical data. Methodists Adam Clarke and John Wesley in their commentaries simply make the prayers presented in 5:8 figurative. Clarke makes a rather curious assertion concerning Revelation 8:3-4:
"It is not said that the angel presents these prayers. He presents the incense, and the prayers ascend with it."
But the incense is the prayers of the saints in Revelation 5:8, making Clarke’s contention implausible. Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown do some eisegesis of their own in commenting on 8:3-4 (capitalization in original):
How precisely their ministry, in perfuming the prayers of the saints and offering them on the altar of incense, is exercised, we know not, but we do know they are not to be prayed TO . . . It is not the saints who give the angel the incense; nor are their prayers identified with the incense; nor do they offer their prayers to him. Christ alone is the Mediator through whom, and to whom, prayer is to be offered.
How, indeed, do we know the angels are not asked to intercede? For it stands to reason that they would be offering the prayers of the saints only if they were asked to – otherwise those prayers would not be, in a sense, theirs to offer.
Taken flatly denies this.
Lastly, the fact that Christ is mediator is not questioned by anyone. Asking a saint in heaven to pray for us no more interferes with the unique mediation of Christ than does asking a person on earth to pray for us.
We always pray in Christ, through His power, and to Him, whether it is directly to Him, or by means of another person or angel, in heaven or on earth.
This gives not the least sanction to Rome’s dogma of our praying to saints. Though they be employed by God in some way unknown to us to present our prayers (nothing is said of their interceding for us), yet we are told to pray only to Him (Rev. 19:10; 22:8, 9).
We are not told in Scripture that we cannot ask someone in heaven to pray for us. Saints in heaven are more alive and aware and far more holy than we are. They watch us (Heb. 12:1). They are aware of earthly happenings (Rev. 6:9-10). They can certainly be given extraordinary capacities for knowledge by God; there is nothing implausible or intrinsically impossible or unbiblical in that notion at all.
St. Paul states about the afterlife in heaven:
1 Corinthians 13:12 For now we see in a mirror dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall understand fully, even as I have been fully understood.
Therefore, they can pray for us and we can ask for their prayers. We know that they can come back to earth (from the four examples given earlier). Are we to believe that when such saints come to earth they can pray, but immediately upon returning to heaven they cannot once again?
And if they can present our prayers, why is it so inconceivable that they could intercede for us?
Albert Barnes in his comment on both Revelation 5:8 and 8:3 draws some hairsplitting distinctions that would make the most skillful lawyer envious:
Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown’s comment on Revelation 5:8 exhibits even more of a sort of “fortress mentality”:
Abraham / rich man…Their Body’s were DEAD.
Living souls depart out of Dead body’s.
Two departed living souls…can communicate.
So the rich man is not seeking Abraham's intercession? Obviously, being dead does not disqualify a person from interceding. And neither does being alive on earth.
Was the dead rich man asking Abraham a question…yes…so?
Was the dead rich man praising Abraham? No…
Worshiping Abraham? No.
Thanking Abraham? No.
Asking for help for his errant brothers on earth,
yes, that you deny.
You think every time you ask someone a question you are “Spiritually PRAYING” to them?
Another headless chicken comment.

I ask you questions and you instantly become deaf.
Taken's (false) dichotomy between Christ’s mediation and human or angelic mediation need not be drawn at all; it arises only because of the Protestant’s
needless alarmism at God’s making use of creatures to fulfill his purposes.