The 10 Commandments are FOREVER

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

Status
Not open for further replies.

M3n0r4h

Active Member
Jun 3, 2023
425
159
43
South
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Entirely possible, yes.
Don't discount those who follow the Replacement Theology (false) doctrine.
I've heard multiple definitions for what Replacement Theology actually is.

I don't believe the church (or all True Bible-believing, Holy Spirit-filled Christians) has replaced any "race" of people, I believe they are now, and always were, the True People of God all along.

if the RT concept is that the people of the state of Israel are God's People, that's just plain false.

they themselves don't even claim that, they couldn't care less about Jesus and the majority of them are atheist.

what is your understood definition of RT?
 

Jim B

Well-Known Member
Jun 5, 2020
5,793
1,799
113
Santa Fe NM
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
so your silly theory is that those who walked right beside Jesus Christ and were taught from His mouth to their ears were clueless about what He expected of them after His Crucifixion?

I see you blushing about that one.

it's okay, I'd be embarrassed too if I'd suggested something that ridiculous.

wanna try again?
Who is being "silly"? YOU are the one who is wrong about the law and the New Covenant.
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I've heard multiple definitions for what Replacement Theology actually is.

I don't believe the church (or all True Bible-believing, Holy Spirit-filled Christians) has replaced any "race" of people, I believe they are now, and always were, the True People of God all along.

if the RT concept is that the people of the state of Israel are God's People, that's just plain false.

they themselves don't even claim that, they couldn't care less about Jesus and the majority of them are atheist.

what is your understood definition of RT?
God replaced the status of his chosen people with gentiles due to the Jews obstinance, and as fulfillment of the curse they laid upon their own heads with his crucifixion.

‘His Blood be Upon Us and Upon our Children’.
 

Jim B

Well-Known Member
Jun 5, 2020
5,793
1,799
113
Santa Fe NM
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
God replaced the status of his chosen people with gentiles due to the Jews obstinance, and as fulfillment of the curse they laid upon their own heads with his crucifixion.

‘His Blood be Upon Us and Upon our Children’.
This is nonsense. Jesus was a Jew, as were all the apostles and all the New Testament authors and all the members of the early church. Gentiles came in later.

You should read Romans 11 and learn the truth about Jews and gentiles.
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
This is nonsense. Jesus was a Jew, as were all the apostles and all the New Testament authors and all the members of the early church. Gentiles came in later.

You should read Romans 11 and learn the truth about Jews and gentiles.
You addressed that reply to those here who advocate Replacement Theology.
 

M3n0r4h

Active Member
Jun 3, 2023
425
159
43
South
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
God replaced the status of his chosen people with gentiles due to the Jews obstinance, and as fulfillment of the curse they laid upon their own heads with his crucifixion.

‘His Blood be Upon Us and Upon our Children’.
does it make any sense to you that the people who killed Jesus were God's own people?

who do you understand to be the people Jesus excoriated and publicly humiliated every day?

who do you think are the people Jesus plainly stated He refused to reveal the Truth to and stated that it was NOT given to them to know the mysteries of the Kingdom?

who do you believe it was that Jesus HATED with a passion and made that undebatably clear in Matt. 23 and John 8?

and if you believe the answer to all those questions is the jews, then who do you believe He was spending personal time with and teaching throughout His ministry? because they were most certainly not the same people.

God's people loved Him and loved all of His Law.

the people in question above hated God and His Law and Jesus makes it very clear in Matt. 23:1-3 and Luke speaks of it in Acts 7:43 when he declares that those people worshipped/served another god altogether.
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
does it make any sense to you that the people who killed Jesus were God's own people?

who do you understand to be the people Jesus excoriated and publicly humiliated every day?

who do you think are the people Jesus plainly stated He refused to reveal the Truth to and stated that it was NOT given to them to know the mysteries of the Kingdom?

who do you believe it was that Jesus HATED with a passion and made that undebatably clear in Matt. 23 and John 8?

and if you believe the answer to all those questions is the jews, then who do you believe He was spending personal time with and teaching throughout His ministry? because they were most certainly not the same people.

God's people loved Him and loved all of His Law.

the people in question above hated God and His Law and Jesus makes it very clear in Matt. 23:1-3 and Luke speaks of it in Acts 7:43 when he declares that those people worshipped/served another god altogether.
I'll say this again so that you and Jim B might get it this time.

I REFERRED TO REPLACEMENT THEOLOGY AS A FALSE DOCTRINE. I WAS ASKED MY UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT RT MEANT. I REPLIED.

IF SOMEONE REFERS TO RT AS FALSE DOCTRINE IT MEANS THEY ARE NOT SOMEONE WHO FOLLOWS RT.

UNDERSTOOD?
NOW DO YOU GET IT?
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
9 of the 10 are in the New Covenant. No Sabbath commands.

Do you obey the Law?

Exodus 31:15
15 Whoever does any work on the Sabbath day, he shall surely be put to death.

Nice Fairy Tale.
You really don't know scripture at all. I thought so but now I see it. Thank you.
 

Jim B

Well-Known Member
Jun 5, 2020
5,793
1,799
113
Santa Fe NM
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
does it make any sense to you that the people who killed Jesus were God's own people?

who do you understand to be the people Jesus excoriated and publicly humiliated every day?

who do you think are the people Jesus plainly stated He refused to reveal the Truth to and stated that it was NOT given to them to know the mysteries of the Kingdom?

who do you believe it was that Jesus HATED with a passion and made that undebatably clear in Matt. 23 and John 8?

and if you believe the answer to all those questions is the jews, then who do you believe He was spending personal time with and teaching throughout His ministry? because they were most certainly not the same people.

God's people loved Him and loved all of His Law.

the people in question above hated God and His Law and Jesus makes it very clear in Matt. 23:1-3 and Luke speaks of it in Acts 7:43 when he declares that those people worshipped/served another god altogether.
The Romans killed Jesus. Read your Bible.

The people whom Jesus excoriated and publicly humiliated every day were the Pharisees, the scribes, and the Sadducees, not all Jews. Matthew 23:1-3, "Then Jesus said to the crowds and to his disciples, “The scribes and the Pharisees sit on Moses’s seat; therefore, do whatever they teach you and follow it, but do not do as they do, for they do not practice what they teach".

All His disciples were Jews.

The entire Bible, both the Old Testament and the New Testament was written by Jews, with one exception: Luke.

All the members of the first churches were Jews.

Your unfounded antiSemitism is abhorrent. Read Romans 12 and ask God to forgive you for your attitude toward His chosen people.
 

M3n0r4h

Active Member
Jun 3, 2023
425
159
43
South
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I'll say this again so that you and Jim B might get it this time.

I REFERRED TO REPLACEMENT THEOLOGY AS A FALSE DOCTRINE. I WAS ASKED MY UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT RT MEANT. I REPLIED.

IF SOMEONE REFERS TO RT AS FALSE DOCTRINE IT MEANS THEY ARE NOT SOMEONE WHO FOLLOWS RT.

UNDERSTOOD?
NOW DO YOU GET IT?
no, you weren't very clear about where exactly you stood on it.

you said you didn't agree with it, but you seemed to imply you agreed that the jews were God's chosen people so that's why my post 2,266.

anywho, ...

THE TEN COMMANDMENTS ARE FOREVER!

THEY STILL, AND ALWAYS WILL, APPLY TO TRUE CHRISTIANS!

GOD BLESS ALL TRUE CHRISTIANS!
 

Jack

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
11,410
4,675
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
so your silly theory is that those who walked right beside Jesus Christ and were taught from His mouth to their ears were clueless about what He expected of them after His Crucifixion?
Actually they worked on the Sabbath and Jesus was with them. Jesus didn't have them executed as the Law COMMANDS!
I see you blushing about that one.

it's okay, I'd be embarrassed too if I'd suggested something that ridiculous.

wanna try again?
You must be looking in your mirror.
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
no, you weren't very clear about where exactly you stood on it.

you said you didn't agree with it, but you seemed to imply you agreed that the jews were God's chosen people so that's why my post 2,266.

anywho, ...

THE TEN COMMANDMENTS ARE FOREVER!

THEY STILL, AND ALWAYS WILL, APPLY TO TRUE CHRISTIANS!

GOD BLESS ALL TRUE CHRISTIANS!
Incorrect.

Implying I'm not a true Christian is pathetic.
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Gee, I quoted Scripture and you didn't. You don't obey the Law. There's lots of Law preachers but none of them obey the Law!
Excising a passage to support your errancy is quoting scripture to foster false teachings.

You are doing what Jesus said would happen as one who thinks to deceive even his elect.
 

Brakelite

Well-Known Member
Feb 6, 2020
9,899
7,170
113
Melbourne
brakelite.wordpress.com
Faith
Christian
Country
Australia
Which commandments? The Law of Moses or the NT? I don't know of anyone who obeys the Law. Galatians is clearly explaining that we are not under the Law, period. We have the New Covenant that Jesus shed His Blood for.

Galatians 5:1-4 (NKJV)
1 Stand fast therefore in the liberty by which Christ has made us free, and do not be entangled again with a yoke of bondage.
2 Indeed I, Paul, say to you that if you become circumcised, Christ will profit you nothing.
3 And I testify again to every man who becomes circumcised that he is a debtor to keep the whole law.
4 You have become estranged from Christ, you who attempt to be justified by law; you have fallen from grace.
So now we are talking about circumcision? You really think we are advocating for circumcision in order to be justified?
Christ died to set us free from the tyranny of the OT law.
Yet Paul called the law holy, just, and good.
Paul would "criticize" you for picking the parts of the Law you like and ignoring the rest.
I keep those parts of the law that are applicable to NT Christians, and humanity in general. I don't live under a theocracy that requires me to inflict death upon sinners. And even Jim actually agrees with me that we ought to be obeying those commandments that reflect love for neighbor etc, as he detailed above. (Rom 8:4; 13:10) Surely you don't disagree with that.
Although I disagree with him that I am twisting the conversation. The topic is, the "Ten Commandments are forever". Jim seems to think they are, in fact he says it is the holy Spirit that prompts and changes our hearts and minds to obey, by changing our very nature from
A. darkness to light, Eph 5:8
B. from disobedience to obedience Rom. 6:15-22
C. From being under the authority of the prince of this world to the authority of Christ.

But we all knew that didn't we. I know that you have no real problem with 9 of the Commandments. The only one you have any issue with is the 4th, and in a pique of emotional hip shooting, find it necessary to throw all the commandments out as being a tyranny and a bondage. Sad that you fellas think it a tyranny and a bondage to be faithful to your wife and refrain from stealing your neighbors car. I'm kidding, I actually don't think you really believe that...
Why are you still talking about my wife and my marriage? You know ZERO about us.
Notwithstanding.

but nor do I think you have really thought through all your arguments.
It's actually all about C above. It's about authority. Who is your Lord? Do you seek to obey your Lord in all things applicable to loving Him with all your heart, soul, mind, and heart, and you neighbor as yourself, or are you on the throne dictating to yourself what is expedient with regards commandment number 4? Which gets back to what one of said about obeying the laws you like, and ignoring the ones you don't like.
There are 3 authorities vying for attention here. Satan, who uses earthly powers to enforce false doctrine through legislation and deception... Your own heart that doesn't like to obey in those areas that prove difficult, awkward, embarrassing, or costly... And Jesus, who was the Lawgiver on Sinai and who is the same yesterday, today, and forever. It's that 4th commandment that is a stumbling block isn't it. But in order to defend your rejection of the 4th, you have to justify throwing out everything, calling it "the law of Moses" and a tyranny and a bondage...which my friends includes the 7th commandment.
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
So now we are talking about circumcision? You really think we are advocating for circumcision in order to be justified?

Yet Paul called the law holy, just, and good.

I keep those parts of the law that are applicable to NT Christians, and humanity in general. I don't live under a theocracy that requires me to inflict death upon sinners. And even Jim actually agrees with me that we ought to be obeying those commandments that reflect love for neighbor etc, as he detailed above. (Rom 8:4; 13:10) Surely you don't disagree with that.
Although I disagree with him that I am twisting the conversation. The topic is, the "Ten Commandments are forever". Jim seems to think they are, in fact he says it is the holy Spirit that prompts and changes our hearts and minds to obey, by changing our very nature from
A. darkness to light, Eph 5:8
B. from disobedience to obedience Rom. 6:15-22
C. From being under the authority of the prince of this world to the authority of Christ.

But we all knew that didn't we. I know that you have no real problem with 9 of the Commandments. The only one you have any issue with is the 4th, and in a pique of emotional hip shooting, find it necessary to throw all the commandments out as being a tyranny and a bondage. Sad that you fellas think it a tyranny and a bondage to be faithful to your wife and refrain from stealing your neighbors car. I'm kidding, I actually don't think you really believe that...

Notwithstanding.

but nor do I think you have really thought through all your arguments.
It's actually all about C above. It's about authority. Who is your Lord? Do you seek to obey your Lord in all things applicable to loving Him with all your heart, soul, mind, and heart, and you neighbor as yourself, or are you on the throne dictating to yourself what is expedient with regards commandment number 4? Which gets back to what one of said about obeying the laws you like, and ignoring the ones you don't like.
There are 3 authorities vying for attention here. Satan, who uses earthly powers to enforce false doctrine through legislation and deception... Your own heart that doesn't like to obey in those areas that prove difficult, awkward, embarrassing, or costly... And Jesus, who was the Lawgiver on Sinai and who is the same yesterday, today, and forever. It's that 4th commandment that is a stumbling block isn't it. But in order to defend your rejection of the 4th, you have to justify throwing out everything, calling it "the law of Moses" and a tyranny and a bondage...which my friends includes the 7th commandment.
Jesus said the ten commandments are synopsized in two. And if we read them, we find that's true.

Love the Lord with all our hearts and minds. Love our neighbor as ourselves.
On those two commands hang all the law and the prophets.

The Sabbath command , the Sabbath, was yet another of God's gifts.
He created the Sabbath for us. Not us for the Sabbath.

Jesus never repealed any of the ten commandments. In fact he said, if we love him we will obey his commandments.

If someone wants to ignore God's Sabbath gift, that's their prerogative. However, it was not something Jesus set aside.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brakelite

Jack

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
11,410
4,675
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
So now we are talking about circumcision? You really think we are advocating for circumcision in order to be justified?
Circumcision is a COMMANDMENT in the Law of Moses.
Yet Paul called the law holy, just, and good.

I keep those parts of the law that are applicable to NT Christians, and humanity in general. I don't live under a theocracy that requires me to inflict death upon sinners. And even Jim actually agrees with me that we ought to be obeying those commandments that reflect love for neighbor etc, as he detailed above. (Rom 8:4; 13:10) Surely you don't disagree with that.
IOW, you keep the parts you like. Just like all the Law preachers I have debated. You can't do that!

Galatians 5:3-4
3 And I testify again to every man who becomes circumcised that he is a debtor to keep the whole law.
4 You have become estranged from Christ, you who attempt to be justified by law; you have fallen from grace.

And that ain't good.

Although I disagree with him that I am twisting the conversation. The topic is, the "Ten Commandments are forever". Jim seems to think they are, in fact he says it is the holy Spirit that prompts and changes our hearts and minds to obey, by changing our very nature from
A. darkness to light, Eph 5:8
B. from disobedience to obedience Rom. 6:15-22
C. From being under the authority of the prince of this world to the authority of Christ.

But we all knew that didn't we. I know that you have no real problem with 9 of the Commandments. The only one you have any issue with is the 4th, and in a pique of emotional hip shooting, find it necessary to throw all the commandments out as being a tyranny and a bondage. Sad that you fellas think it a tyranny and a bondage to be faithful to your wife and refrain from stealing your neighbors car. I'm kidding, I actually don't think you really believe that...

Notwithstanding.

but nor do I think you have really thought through all your arguments.
It's actually all about C above. It's about authority. Who is your Lord? Do you seek to obey your Lord in all things applicable to loving Him with all your heart, soul, mind, and heart, and you neighbor as yourself, or are you on the throne dictating to yourself what is expedient with regards commandment number 4? Which gets back to what one of said about obeying the laws you like, and ignoring the ones you don't like.
There are 3 authorities vying for attention here. Satan, who uses earthly powers to enforce false doctrine through legislation and deception... Your own heart that doesn't like to obey in those areas that prove difficult, awkward, embarrassing, or costly... And Jesus, who was the Lawgiver on Sinai and who is the same yesterday, today, and forever. It's that 4th commandment that is a stumbling block isn't it. But in order to defend your rejection of the 4th, you have to justify throwing out everything, calling it "the law of Moses" and a tyranny and a bondage...which my friends includes the 7th commandment.
Jesus called it "the Law of Moses". Stick with the New Covenant. You won't find salvation under the Law.
 

Jack

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2022
11,410
4,675
113
Midwest
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Jesus said the ten commandments are synopsized in two. And if we read them, we find that's true.

Love the Lord with all our hearts and minds. Love our neighbor as ourselves.
On those two commands hang all the law and the prophets.

The Sabbath command , the Sabbath, was yet another of God's gifts.
He created the Sabbath for us. Not us for the Sabbath.

Jesus never repealed any of the ten commandments. In fact he said, if we love him we will obey his commandments.

If someone wants to ignore God's Sabbath gift, that's their prerogative. However, it was not something Jesus set aside.
Jesus was with His disciples working on the Sabbath. No Sabbath commands in the New Covenant!
 

ButterflyJones

Well-Known Member
Feb 19, 2023
1,575
1,239
113
USA
youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Jesus was with His disciples working on the Sabbath. No Sabbath commands in the New Covenant!
What NT passage revoked God's Sabbath gift to us?

When the Pharisees and Sadducees accused Jesus of breaking the law by working on the Sabbath they were referring to that of the Halakah. An extra biblical hedge they invented to insure God's actual law would not be violated.

Jesus knew this. And his working on the Sabbath did not violate his law, but theirs.
Which is why and how Jesus proved whose law is righteous being Jesus could not sin.


"Yet I say to you that in this place there is One greater than the temple. But if you had known what this means, 'I desire mercy and not sacrifice,' you would not have condemned the guiltless. For the Son of Man is Lord even of the Sabbath" Matthew 12:6-8


Matthew 12:12 "... Therefore it is lawful to do good on the Sabbath.”
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Brakelite
Status
Not open for further replies.