Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.
You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
Michael V Pardo said:"Maybe rjp has an answer for you, but I can certainly think of a few countries that don't have long records of internal abuse or international violence..."
Hello Tom,tom55 said:Michael V Pardo
So what is YOUR answer? Name those "few countries". I am curious! :unsure:
Michael V Pardo said:Hello Tom,
My maternal grandparents were of Slovak descent, one born there, the other here. I don't know what the dominant ethnicities are now, but Slovakia was once a part of the Austrian-Hungarian Empire, and became part of the nation of Czechoslovakia during the Nazi regime in Germany. The reason that they typically were part of some other empire was because the people native to the area were mostly agrarian, predominantly Catholic, unaggressive toward their neighbors, generally friendly toward strangers, and generally a peaceful people. Such people tend to be easy conquests for imperial regimes. The reason my grandparent's families emigrated to the U.S. was for a chance of economic prosperity and to avoid conflicts in Europe. My paternal grandparents were from Spain, which has a long history of imperial and colonial endeavors. They emigrated to the U.S. primarily for a chance of economic prosperity and to avoid conflicts in Spain (a civil war,) and Europe in general (WW I and the threat of another.)
The original colonists that founded the U.S. had similar reasons for coming here, a chance at economic prosperity and to avoid persecutions and conflict. The international image of the U.S. has historically been as a place of potential economic prosperity, and that's been enough to have drawn the bulk of the immigrant population since the days that our nation was founded, e.g. the Chinese immigrants of the 1800's and even many of those who still come here today came because the U.S.A. had "mountains of gold." Gold has always been a great motivator to people with nothing. However, the "blessing" of prosperity and land ownership for some has always been at the cost of others; e.g. the buying and selling of human beings as a labor force first predominantly in the South, but threatening to spread throughout the newer western territories in the years building to our civil war. Not to mention the displacement of native Americans to "unsettled" territories, and then to less and less hospitable "reservations" as the needs of a growing and land greedy population increased. Many professing Christians compared the conquest of the American territories to the conquest of the land of Canaan in order to justify stealing lands from the former inhabitants, but conveniently managed to forget that many of the native Americans had converted to Christianity through the efforts of evangelists, devout priests and monks seeking to bring salvation to "the heathen." Many of the Chinese immigrants found only hard labor, laying track and digging tunnels for the new railroads, rather than their mountains of gold. More than a few found only early graves in desolate places along the railroad waysides. Men like my maternal grandfather spent the bulk of their days in holes in the ground digging coal by lamp light to fuel forges and provide coke for steel production, and other industry. Many received the wages of an early death from "black lung" disease and other industrial hazards that were "just a part of the job."
It wasn't until the late 1800s that the nation had managed to fully subjugate the native peoples and establish a nation sea to sea controlled by the extremely wealthy, and fueled largely by the hard labor of a predominantly immigrant work force. If it weren't for the rise of the threat of communism in Europe, and the western answer of "labor unions" in our nation, we most likely would have become a dictatorship or oligarchy already.
The nation was founded largely upon those noble documents that we call our constitution and bill of rights, but corrupt judges installed by elitist presidents with the agenda of increasing federal power have reinterpreted the constitution and in many ways abrogated both that document and the bill of rights. If you're interested in pursuing an understanding of the events and decisions that have corrupted the vision of our founders, I would recommend a book written by Mark Levin entitled "Men in Black" that presents an accurate history of the corruption of the judiciary through Supreme court decisions based upon biases and reinterpretations of the intent of the documents upon which our nation was founded. While Levin represents a view of extreme conservatism in general, the man is well educated in constitutional law and its history. The "Politically incorrect guide to The Founding Fathers" is also very revealing with regard to the formation of our nation, the rise of the landowner and industrial elite, and the somewhat flawed motives of those who committed such high ideals of freedom and liberty to our understanding of national politics.
While in University studies, I read and had to write some papers upon a few ethnographic studies for a course in anthropology which helped me to understand the "western" agenda. I read about the Yanamamo people of the Amazon river basin, the Ba'mbuti of the Congo, the Semai of Malasia, and a few others whose names I no longer recall. Most of these people no longer exist in their native environments and what cultures they've had are largely destroyed and absorbed by those who were either more aggressive or more persistent and better armed. The problem that all these people had in common was the incursion of other people who wanted to profit by the land that they occupied. The job of field anthropologists has been primarily to do studies of indigenous peoples prior to their invasion by entrepreneurs. Cultural homogeneity allows marketers to maximize the profits of industrial producers: i.e. if you can alter the values of peoples to crass and self indulgent pursuit you can create large and manageable markets for consumables. If that's what makes a nation great, then we certainly are among the best. If expertise in exploitation is admirable, then we can certainly glory in that as well. Before you judge any of us too harshly, perhaps you should consider that as Christians we are called to expose the deeds of darkness, not rationalize them because we have benefited by them or through them. God used Babylon to bring judgment against Israel, but He also placed His people in Babylon to gain benefit through Babylon's prosperity. However, He never intended for them to become Babylonians themselves.
What a silly statement. Laws that stop us from worshiping God? No law can stop us from worshiping God. Even in death we will worship him. People like you have been saying the same thing about this great country for 100 years; we have lost our greatness. Your a new messenger with an old message.Mr.Bride said:America was once a great country when people would listen to God. Now you have laws set forth and ones that are coming to pass to stop you from worship or obeying God. The majority of the leaders are heathen. The few that love God are overwhelmed by the many. Don't deceive yourself about America. It is done. They have crossed the line and cannot return. They've rejected Jesus Christ. There's no hope for America as a nation. God is now dealing with us as individuals. You can't hide how corrupt this nation has become. Priorities all messed up. 9 where the 2 supposed to be and 4 where there's supposed to be 21. Yes it is now a force for evil. Gods chosen can only shine lights into this darkness and show forth His glory.
America: Another story of how a prosperous, God-fearing nation can degenerate and decay. We were "The Nation" and there won't be another like we were. We are in the last days.
Don't deceive yourself. Just take a trip down history lane. We were who we were because we kept God in our view. Is that being done today? The devil has infiltrated and corrupted almost every good thing. Instead of praying in council meetings, you have a moment of silence. So you won't offend others. Allowing gays to marry. No prayer in schools but place your hand over your heart to recite a pledge of allegiance to the United States. Every morning. But now they wanna take "under God" out of it. Teaching children that we came from monkeys. Indoctrinating them with lies from the start. Question: Who's stopping this foolish, perverseness? It's not perverse to them though but become "modernized". The Bible is out of date to the "powers that be". They don't give a rip about those kind of things.tom55 said:Michael Pardo:
Thanks for educating us about your family history and some personal experiences in your life. However, you didn't answer my question! Unless I missed the answer in your extensive response? You did mention Israel in your post. So I will start it off. I think Israel is as great a nation as America is. Now it's your turn.......
What a silly statement. Laws that stop us from worshiping God? No law can stop us from worshiping God. Even in death we will worship him. People like you have been saying the same thing about this great country for 100 years; we have lost our greatness. Your a new messenger with an old message.
How are we a force for evil?
What nation is greater than America if we have, according to you, fallen so far? Because if we have fallen, we have fallen below other's. Who are those other's?
Israel works for me. I'd be content to live out the rest of my life there, but I don't think my wife would enjoy it much. Australia seems like a pretty good place to live too, but I know that they have some history of internal abuses with their aboriginal population. Other than that you don't generally hear much that's bad about the place. Switzerland appears to have a pretty good record, but again the truth of the matter is that I was born in the USA and lived here for all of my 57 years. Its never been a perfect place in my experience, but it certainly isn't the same nation that I grew up in. I've taken to spending some of my free time watching old TV shows aired on channel 19 on my TV provider, same shows that I grew up with. Its not that I'm particularly nostalgic about my youth, but the comedies weren't full of perverse behavior and language (more like subtle suggestiveness than overt lewd, crude, and rude behavior.) The crime dramas and westerns had their share of violence (sometimes some sexual innuendo as with the latter types), but were by no means "graphic" in presenting evil behavior (they had more rigorous censorship back then.)tom55 said:Michael Pardo:
Thanks for educating us about your family history and some personal experiences in your life. However, you didn't answer my question! Unless I missed the answer in your extensive response? You did mention Israel in your post. So I will start it off. I think Israel is as great a nation as America is. Now it's your turn.......
Mr. Pardo wrote: "We are an exceptional country."tom55 said:Michael V Pardo
I say to you RJP:
The only thing I would add to his great statement is that America, unlike other countries that have conquered other nations, has helped those countries rebuild after we have defeated them. BECAUSE WE ARE AN EXPECTIONAL COUNTRY!
It is a force of goodness and rightness. And its rockets and bombs fly to make the world more beautiful. :unsure:John S said:Is the U.S a force for evil - NO.
No I didn't. You quoted someone who responded to one of my previous posts. Countries aren't exceptional, but a person might be.[email protected] said:Mr. Pardo wrote: "We are an exceptional country."
Is that supposed to be a joke? God has placed a curse upon those that destroy the earth. I don't know if that guilt falls upon nations or upon economic systems, but nations are made up of peoples and peoples develop economic systems in order to store up wealth or manage its use. Rulers don't rule for long without consent of the governed; rebellion is within our (fallen) nature.Andrey son of Lion said:It is a force of goodness and rightness. And its rockets and bombs fly to make the world more beautiful. :unsure:
Such a person could never run as a Democrat and would be kicking the goads to run as a Republican.marksman,
Thank you for your compliments of our great country. I believe that satan is attacking the religious and morale fiber of this country and his focus is on our politicians/government. I was shocked when President Obama was voted back into office. I understood how he got into office on the first election, however, once the people could see who he really was I honestly didn't think he would be re-elected. God willing we will have big changes in 2016. I don't necessarily mean a republican but a God fearing person who will work for ALL citizens.
Rather than address every single point, I chose one.tom55 said:Dear rjp34652,
Out of all the things I said about our great country the only response you have is to contend one word I wrote? EXCEPTIONAL
[email protected] said:Rather than address every single point, I chose one.
(when you read this don't take it as me being mad, just direct)
You didn't address ONE point of mine, you addressed ONE word....and you failed at that.
I did that mostly to learn how you'd respond. I pretty much figured that although you wouldn't like my explanation you couldn't deny its veracity. You couldn't deny any of the other statements I made either. I wanted to see if you'd try. You didn't.
I can deny the statement that you made about Stalin. He was not the first to use the word "exceptional" about America. Alexis Tocquevil did in 1831.
I also wanted to find out if you were a thinking person or just another fool who wraps himself in the flag without reckoning what it means in the context of political and historic fact. You are a thinker and a reasonable person, apparently.
I am a student of history and I know the bad history of this great country. As stated before our good far outweighs our bad. We are a great country and you haven't and can't name a country greater than ours. Because if you could have, you would have.
I suspect that the main reason most of us are gathered here is for intellectual stimulation we don't get elsewhere. I could be wrong on this. Correct me if I am.
Finally, we agree on something. I believe you are right! :) But just because everyone doesn't seek out this stimulation doesn't mean they are any less religious than you or I.
I personally agree with those who openly state that they love this country but hate this government.
Our government is made of laws, not politicians. Our Constitution is what makes America great.....if our politicians would follow it and hold accountable in court those who don't.
My purpose in writing the things I wrote was to educate Tom as well as the readership as to the real nature of the history of America. It is no shining light in the world today or in the past. If a light is sought, then the cross of Christ Jesus is that which will never disappoint. To worship America, to assume that all is right and proper and decent, to assume that it has always been that way and always will be so is to invite cultural, political and spiritual disaster. "My country right or wrong" does not appear in the pages of Holy Writ.
You have failed to educate me on anything except that it seems to me you don't like America and can not name a country that is greater. You are failing to separate the discussion of the greatness of a country from the greatness of our Christ. One can love their country and love Him. Just because I love you does that mean I can't love my spouse? They are two separate things and two different kinds of love. The title of this discussion is: Is America becoming a force for evil in the world? I have contended that America is a force for good in this world. Even though it has done some bad.
Some would say we have openly invited disaster by insulting and rejecting the only hope this nation (or any other) really has - Almighty God.
"SOME" would say the opposite. So who is right?
Pride goes before a fall, someone once said. If true then America has puffed itself up so much that it can no longer see where it's walking. At this point in our history stumbling is inevitable.
"Pride goes before fall is not from someone...it is almost an exact quote from the bible. It seems you are saying since Americans take pride in who they are then America will fall? If you feel you are being prophetic then spare me. Every nation falls eventually. Are you proud of who you are? Then you will fall. So if you take no pride in yourself, you will never fall?
We have not arrived at a utopian society in America, not by a long shot.
We (man) will never have utopia until we are in heaven. If you, RJP, are looking for perfection in man or any country you will never find it. Therefor we must grade ourselves on a bell curve. Upon grading all the countries of the world on a bell curve America would be considered exceptional = superior, unusually excellent.
We need to have a firm appreciation of what is wrong before we can begin to work at fixing it right. No one will seek a doctor until they are convinced they are sick. And this nation is sick.
RJP, If you think our nation is sick now then the state of our nation seems to have been a lot worse (sick) in the past. (Read my previous post to Mr. Pride) Historically speaking we had a fever not to many years ago and now we are getting better. I thank God that He has helped America see the errors of her ways and has helped us to become an exceptional country. We were very sick and have become better.
You, RJP, seem to take great pride in what you have to say. You say what you believe with conviction and I like that! But you have not named a country that is greater than America. It doesn't mean you think that country is a utopian society. It just means, based on a curve, it is greater than most other countries. What is your country of choice? I look forward to your answer.