I would define mysticism as man's attempts to experience what mystics call a "mystical union" or "ecstatic union" with God using some form of "spiritual disciplines" or practices NOT taught in the Bible.
I think there were schools for prophets in the Old Testament?
If these practices were a way to experience union with God, the apostles would have practiced and taught these spiritual disciplines to the early church, but we see no evidence of this in the Bible. What IS taught in the Bible is the gifts of the Holy Spirit. I'll address this in a minute.
I'm not sure what we call Christianity was what Jesus came to establish. Remember how quickly Israel fell into rebellion? I see Christianity also falling into darkness rather quickly. Remember Jesus saying the night was coming when no man could work?
Paul uses the term "mystery" to describe the union of Christ and the Church, but this is seen as a "mystical" experience by mystics. I see these as being very different. Our union with Jesus Christ is a mystery just as a husband and wife becoming one flesh is a mystery, but we do not enter a mystical union with Him whereby we are melded into Him and lose our distinction as humans. IOW, we don't become Jesus Christ or God.
The Jews had their mysteries. If Paul studied with Gamaliel, he would have know about some of them. John also seems to have known about some. Neither get too explicit when it comes to certain subjects; and people who read them can often get misled. Peter also knew something of them. He wrote:
2 Peter 3:15 And account that the longsuffering of our Lord is salvation; even as our beloved brother Paul also according to the wisdom given unto him hath written unto you;
16 As also in all his epistles, speaking in them of these things; in which are some things hard to be understood, which they that are unlearned and unstable wrest, as they do also the other scriptures, unto their own destruction.
The "disciplines" used by mystics include practices such as contemplative prayer (also called breath prayers or centering prayer) in which the person chants a word or short phrase over and over, which is similar to chanting in Eastern meditation. Sadly, breath prayers are taught by Rick Warren in A Purpose-Driven Life. In this book Warren also extensively quotes from the so-called Christian mystics.
I see nothing wrong with it. I'd recommend chanting "Amen" for a while with the intention of God's Will being done in all three heavens and the earth. The Lord's Prayer is also good if you do it slowly focusing on the meaning of each phrase. Many people pray it without thinking.
Like you, I've gotten the creeps in some churches. The devil is always trying to counterfeit the move of the Holy Spirit! So, not all that you see in churches is a genuine move of the HOLY Spirit. It could be a move of another kind of spirit. This is why we need spiritual discernment.
Having said this, it's important not to throw out the baby with bathwater. I do believe that the Holy Spirit still moves in powerful ways in the Church (meaning believers) through the spiritual gifts, which I strongly believe did NOT cease with the apostles as cessationism teaches. That's a whole other can of worms for a different thread. But I believe that cessationism has left a vacuum in the Church which has been filled with mystical beliefs and practices because the power of Holy Spirit has been quenched. So, people are desiring to see God's power, so they seek it through mystical experiences, but I believe that what they find is counterfeit power.
Christianity came to depend almost entirely on two methods of communicating the Spirit to others: Laying on of hands and prayer. Neither one is a guarantee of purity for the seeker of truth. While Catholic bishops claim to be the successors of the Apostles, history shows they lost the abilities of the Apostles. As I said elsewhere recently, I would be afraid to let some priests and bishops lay hands on me, and I'd be equally afraid to let some Pentecostals. I'm not sure what "spirit" they'd be trying to pass on to me. Prayer? People don't seem to know where they should draw the line with what they ask for. If I covet my neighbor's house, I doubt God is going to be hearing me if I pray for Him to give it to me. That's an obvious example, but many people "pray against" other people as if they don't have the right to free will. If I prayed to try to get God to force you to agree with me, that would be black magic. I don't have the right to ask for that.
I certainly would NOT believe such a vision if the "Father" and "Jesus" are saying anything contrary to what They said in the Bible! Which is exactly what happened to Joseph Smith. I'm curious as to why you didn't explain in the "Mormonism" thread what you're saying in this post. It would be a valuable contribution to that thread. Instead, you criticized me for quoting a former Mormon. ;)
The thread was about what an ex-Mormon wrote. I didn't want to venture into a long discussion that derailed it. I also didn't want to "pile on" making Jane think people were ganging up on her. That vision is troubling in more than one way; but Smith should have known that no man can see God and live. Even Buddhists and Hindus wouldn't claim something like that. I skimmed that other thread; but I also didn't see Smith's connections with Freemasons. I'm not slamming Freemasons. No, he seems to have stolen some ideas from them and passed them off to others as his own revelations. He may also have talked too much about some "mysteries" -- I don't know.
As I've said before, there's a HUGE difference between the practices used by mystics and the gifts of the Holy Spirit taught in the Bible and used by believers. These mystical practices are NOT promoted anywhere in the Bible. Nowhere in the Bible are we instructed to chant in order to experience an "ecstatic union" with God like the Eastern mystics do.
And what is the basis for this "mystical union"? It's not Jesus Christ! He is essentially bypassed in the mystical process, and yet, He says in His word that He IS the way to the Father--to experience God Himself. We cannot go any other way--not through some "spiritual disciplines" that are not taught in the Bible. Our very real union with God is through His Holy Spirit indwelling us.
As you can see, I feel very strongly about this issue because I see mysticism as a major tool the devil is using to bring about the great falling away from biblical truth. THIS is the apostasy talked about in the Bible, not what Joseph Smith alleged.
Again I cite what Jesus said about the night coming quickly when no man could work. While I agree somewhat with Smith then, I also think he got parts of the picture and then used those to benefit himself.
There are some things in the Bible that are left unexplained. Why did Jesus breath on his disciples? Why did he speak in parables so other people didn't understand? Over time, men have evolved theories about some things; but I think it fairly clear they're only theories.
I urge you and anyone else dabbling in mysticism to seriously consider what I'm saying. I believe that mystical practices are very dangerous and lead a person the wrong direction into the enemy's camp, not into a closer relationship with God!.
I think it depends on the person's heart. The person seeking "wisdom" to promote himself, to give himself money and power, may learn some things; but he will eventually go down. The person sincerely seeking for God will find. If people are attracted to things for the wrong reasons and go down in ruin, they have the right to do that. God is not mocked. False religion contains within itself the seeds of its own destruction. People can proceed so far and not farther.
We all have free will. God is still on His Throne. All is well. Everything is still going according to God's plan for this world. There is no need to panic or to think the world is so dangerous we have to "fight back." Christian history shows how the early Church fell into persecuting others over disagreements. They did not trust God's plan. They did not respect the Law of Free Will. They fell into spiritual wickedness themselves, trusting the power of the earthly sword over the Power of God.