If We Protestants Truly Hated Catholics...

[Marymog]

Not at all. That is why they are in the Bible. And the canon was established by about 200 AD.

Thank you Enoch.

Luther wanted those NT books to be Apocryphal. Do you believe he was guided by God in his decision to make the OT books Apocryphal but he wasn't guided by God to make the NT books Apocryphal???

Established by 200 AD??? Established by whom???

Historical Mary

 

[Marymog]

I'll answer that.
I don't know.
Tell me.
Please back it up with proof rather than hearsay.

LOL..... for you to suggest it is hearsay shows what you ALREADY BELIEVE.

Read his own writings and then YOU can back it up with proof.

Don't rely on Marymog to educate you on Christian history. Rely on yourself.

Mary

 

[BreadOfLife]

mixing cultures, moving boundary stones, these are guaranteed ways to get peaceful neighbors at each others' throats.
It's not like we are ever going to agree on Mary's role, or Christ's even, heck Christians can't even do that among themselves. Good fences make good neighbors and all that rot

Sooooo - YOU think that you're NOT going to get into any arguments when there are tens of thousands of disjointed and perpetually-splintering sects of Protestantism here who ALL believe that their doctrines are correct??

Should this site only accommodate ONE of those denominations?
If so - WHICH one??

Do you even understand the concept of a discussion/debate forum??
If you're unhappy here - maybe it's YOU who should leave . . .

 

[BreadOfLife]

Not at all. That is why they are in the Bible. And the canon was established by about 200 AD.

383 AD.

 

[Rollo Tamasi]

Sure - right after they cinch YOU into your straightjacket.

I knew you liked me.
I knew you wanted to me with me so I could teach you the truth.

 

[Rollo Tamasi]

Luther and Calvin were militants against the Catholic Church.

It seems to me that you believe as long as one is militant against the Catholic Church it is OK with it you but if one is militant against you or your ilk you are not OK with it???

Hmmmmm........Double standard???

Mary

No, I would simply say this in a mellow low key tone of voice, "you are wrong, again".

 

[Rollo Tamasi]

383 AD.

You think you know everything.
It's 383 AD because "my pope says so".
Talk about being dumb, put yourself at the top of the list next time.

 

[Rollo Tamasi]

LOL..... for you to suggest it is hearsay shows what you ALREADY BELIEVE.

Read his own writings and then YOU can back it up with proof.

Don't rely on Marymog to educate you on Christian history. Rely on yourself.

Mary

Just as I thought
Hearsay from Mary
It's been going around the forum, not my idea

 

[Rollo Tamasi]

Well looks like the truth chased everyone off the forum
Praise you Lord Jesus!

 

[bbyrd009]

Sooooo - YOU think that you're NOT going to get into any arguments when there are tens of thousands of disjointed and perpetually-splintering sects of Protestantism here who ALL believe that their doctrines are correct?

ha you really like that phrase, huh. Nevermind that the Catholic fathers guaranteed this @ Trent, the Clown Council right

so now we're all the splinters lol, not the wolves who sold Indulgences and established Inquisitions and Crusades, and helped steal everyone's land? It's like talking to a record.

 

[BreadOfLife]

You think you know everything.
It's 383 AD because "my pope says so".
Talk about being dumb, put yourself at the top of the list next time.

Then PROVE me wrong.

 

[bbyrd009]

Should this site only accommodate ONE of those denominations?
If so - WHICH one?

any one that does not openly support Fascism and your Cult of Sol Invictus i guess. None are coming to mind tho

Do you even understand the concept of a discussion/debate forum?

do you even understand the concept of Boundary Stones and mixing cultures?

you gave up Christ when you kissed that ring, see--i won't bother you with all the pesky Scriptures--and the worst thing i can imagine is to find some compromise. But i have time, and i guess the RCC is about out of that, so it's not that i have any objections so much, more like no Christian principles can be advanced until one is comfortable knowing it won't get all warped by some papist, wadr.

i have plenty of Scriptural examples, but i guess being a strictly optional Book in your opinion the point would get lost there too. Wouldn't surprise me if you called it (the DRB) "God's Word" either, now that it's all scribed up to suit you.

Why not tell everyone why you are not on a Catholic forum? Hmm?
want me to tell them?

 

[Rollo Tamasi]

Then PROVE me wrong.

Which Mother superior told you?
I'll talk to her personally.

 

[Marymog]

No, I would simply say this in a mellow low key tone of voice, "you are wrong, again".

Since the FACT is that Calvin and Luther were both Catholic and militant against the Catholic Church I KNOW I am not wrong about that and you are ok with their militant attitude.

I am just not sure what Catholic militants you support? Only the militants that SUPPORT the Catholic Church??

Hence the double standard accusation......A militant is OK as long as he is MY militant and supports what I believe ;)

Double standard defined: a rule or principle which is unfairly applied in different ways to different people or groups

You said Calvin and Luther are men of God even though they were not perfect in their teachings. Wouldn't the same hold true for the Pope??? You have made it clear the Pope's have not perfect in their teachings.

If you agree with them, they are men of God. But they are disgusting if you don't agree with them????....fascinating.

Did the Holy Spirit guide you to this conclusion???

Mary

 

[tooldtocare]

Too many for this thread...it would be a book!!!

I would be satisfied if you could list two (2) differences between--

Baptists
Presbyterians
Catholics
Judaisms

Thank you in advance

 

[tooldtocare]

The historic Catholic Church is the original true church, but it is not the only church with truths. That statement gives Protestants fits when it doesn't need to.

First you say the differences are to broad to list here and then you state "The historic Catholic Church is the original true church"

This is a good beginning, now state the differences between the other three (3) religions
thanks in advance

 

[Marymog]

You think you know everything.
It's 383 AD because "my pope says so".
Talk about being dumb, put yourself at the top of the list next time.

Wow.....calling someone dumb on a public discussion board is pretty sad. It gives the appearance you have lost the argument so you are resorting to name calling.....

Dear Rollo: It is clear you really don't know your Christian History or where you got that bible full of dust sitting under your couch you occasionally (miss) quote from??? Do some research and learn about YOUR Christian history.

I would never stoop the childish level of calling you dumb like you did @BreadOfLife .....I would say you just lack the desire to learn therefor that makes you un-educated. A dumb person can't learn.....I think YOU can. I don't think you are dumb. I have faith in you. :)

Mary

 

[BreadOfLife]

Which Mother superior told you?
I'll talk to her personally.

In other words - you CAN'T prove me wrong.
That's pretty much what I thought . . .

 

[BreadOfLife]

any one that does not openly support Fascism and your Cult of Sol Invictus i guess. None are coming to mind tho

Funny how you keep perpetuating that whole "Sol Invictus" nonsense when I already proved you wrong about that.

If simple ignorance doesn't perfectly illustrate anti-Catholicism - petty denial certainly does . . .

do you even understand the concept of Boundary Stones and mixing cultures?

you gave up Christ when you kissed that ring, see--i won't bother you with all the pesky Scriptures--and the worst thing i can imagine is to find some compromise. But i have time, and i guess the RCC is about out of that, so it's not that i have any objections so much, more like no Christian principles can be advanced until one is comfortable knowing it won't get all warped by some papist, wadr.

i have plenty of Scriptural examples, but i guess being a strictly optional Book in your opinion the point would get lost there too. Wouldn't surprise me if you called it (the DRB) "God's Word" either, now that it's all scribed up to suit you.

Why not tell everyone why you are not on a Catholic forum? Hmm?
want me to tell them?

First of all - which "ring" did I kiss??
The ONLY ring I remember kissing is the one on my wife's hand when I kissed her hand.

As for your last moronic question - how do YOU know if I'm on a Catholic forum or not??
This isn't the only place I post, Einstein.

 

[BreadOfLife]

ha you really like that phrase, huh. Nevermind that the Catholic fathers guaranteed this @ Trent, the Clown Council right

so now we're all the splinters lol, not the wolves who sold Indulgences and established Inquisitions and Crusades, and helped steal everyone's land? It's like talking to a record.

Care to provide a little historical documentation for that idiotic claim - or are you satisfied just sticking your foot in your mouth?

Stupid accusations are ONE thing - PROVING them is quite another . . .