I asked a supposed "ordained" minister about the morality of abortion

  • Welcome to Christian Forums, a Christian Forum that recognizes that all Christians are a work in progress.

    You will need to register to be able to join in fellowship with Christians all over the world.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

NotTheRock

Well-Known Member
Aug 10, 2024
562
353
63
49
Oklahoma
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Specifically, I asked him if he believes that it's moral for a healthy woman to abort her healthy baby. His response was "It's none of my business".

All I could say was "Wow!".

What do you think about his response?
 

Pearl

Well-Known Member
Staff member
Encounter Team
Apr 9, 2019
12,271
18,798
113
Lancashire
Faith
Christian
Country
United Kingdom
Personally I am against abortion in most cases, but people who do not yet know God through Jesus are still living in the world as sinners and if their governments have made abortion legal then women have free will to decide what's best for them.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Ritajanice

Wrangler

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2021
18,228
7,597
113
56
Shining City on a Hill
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Specifically, I asked him if he believes that it's moral for a healthy woman to abort her healthy baby. His response was "It's none of my business".

All I could say was "Wow!".

What do you think about his response?
To expand this to a higher level, the modern Protestant clergy have made themselves irrelevent by vacating the field of ideas, the field of politics. I am disgusted beyond words! His response is essentially what they say about ANY of the political issues of the day!

I've blasted several pastors who pretend Christians only role in the political process is to be facilitators to both sides. They ignore the fact that God's children are also participants. It is for this reason, I started this thread.

 

MA2444

Well-Known Member
Jan 9, 2024
3,840
1,985
113
62
Columbus Ohio
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
If the supposed ordained Minister has a curch, then his answer was likely motivated by money. He knows taking a stand against abortion will put the spot light on him for a lot of criticism and confrontations, because the world is in a hoe phase where sexual immorality is the norm, and until recently was even sanctioned by the govt which is under control of higher plane evil spirits in the spiritual war.

Good Christians must speak truth regardless of if the crazies will come or not. We know they will, scripture says they will. The world will hate you because it hated Him first and there is where you must stand on your spiritual feet in defiance of evil by identifying with the Lord and truth, enforcing the victory that Christ has already won.

See, I'm not even really from earth, I know that now. I am a spiritual being on a human journey in an old rusty Nova body. I hit too hard when I first landed here. Maybe the doctor slapped me too hard?! But I woke up with amnesia and couldn't remember where I was from or why I was here on house arrest in my aging rusty nova. I did find the Field Manual and the Radio! Let me tell you what a comforting feeling it is to know that I have a built in hotline to the very throne room of God, the real God! I haven't ever had to call in an air strike yet and by the grace of God I wont have to, lol. I read Elijah called in an air strike in scripture, remember?!

So I'm not from here and my mission wasn't to come here and come into agreement with evil spirits that made abortion possible and a thing and make no mistake it is a very real spiritual war. The Lord plays his part, and we are the boots on the ground. So keep your head down (in prayer) and guard your heart diligently from becoming soft enough to celebrate diversity and start accepting some sort of agreement. Hey live and let live, right? Except it isn't. It would be live and let die. Abortion is a huge thing. Don't let the babies get sacrificed to molech or whoever it is. So the reason the minister says not my business you know it's about the money. The women want to be able to use abortion as birth control. How evil is that? Geez. The minute they say not my business they come into agreement with those evil spirits behind that agenda. You can't come into agreement with the evil on this planet because you would be turning your back to God at the same time...and that's not good.

Man, if you ever gave that minister any money, I'd make it a point to help the poor to twice that amount! Don't listen to him no more, lol. It's always about the money because evil pays.
 

VictoryinJesus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2017
10,557
8,404
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Specifically, I asked him if he believes that it's moral for a healthy woman to abort her healthy baby. His response was "It's none of my business".

All I could say was "Wow!".

What do you think about his response?
What is scary to me is with our mouth we confess what we know to be wrong. We are very vocal how those who abort little children are doing wrong. What we never consider is how we know it’s wrong to abort babies…we are confessing it is also wrong to abort the babes of God. as Paul spoke on hindering and enslaving those of Christ and persecuting the way of Faith in Jesus. Preventing others from being born of God. Just like physical and literal murder there is also spiritual murder of brothers devouring brothers. Since we are clear on abortion being wrong…if we then turn around and harm any of the babes coming to Christ then we are also guilty of aborting Gods children before their time of birth in Christ. We may say we have never did that but want all to come to Christ. The Pharisees claimed the same but not only did they not enter in, but they also kept those from entering in that would. Maybe none of that makes since but we must consider while we get puffed up on our own goodness to be so vocal about abortion…are we also guilty of aborting those babes headed to Christ before their birth in Christ?

the pastor may have it right that it’s none of his business, for God will Judge. Because before he stands on a soapbox and shouts his condemnation(appearing righteous before others), he needs to consider if he is also condemned by his own condemnation, by knowing full well …that abortion of God’s children is wrong. Another definition of “babes in Christ” are those still yet carnal and without knowledge…those who lack. I guess what I’m suggesting is…it is a scary thing to end up a hypocrite doing the same thing we condemn others of.
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: Ritajanice

Rockerduck

Well-Known Member
Nov 7, 2022
2,482
2,123
113
70
Marietta, Georgia.
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I am called of God to preach. I don't care where I'm sent, and I will speak the truth. If they don't like it, they can walk away and never come back and I'll tell anyone that too. It is not about money; God will provide for His people. I rather stand before God in truth, than hang my head in shame. I preach the Crucified, Resurrected, and Glorified Christ.
 

VictoryinJesus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2017
10,557
8,404
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I am called of God to preach. I don't care where I'm sent, and I will speak the truth. If they don't like it, they can walk away and never come back and I'll tell anyone that too. It is not about money; God will provide for His people. I rather stand before God in truth, than hang my head in shame. I preach the Crucified, Resurrected, and Glorified Christ.
Personally I think everything out in the world displays a harsh truth of what ought not be going on within the body of Christ. Same with standing up against homosexuals …as vocal and disgusted as homosexuals don’t inherit the kingdom of God …still within the body of Christ there is brothers putting the bottle to their brothers mouth to get their brothers drunk and exposed so they can look on their nakedness. An example being where they were glorying in the one that had his fathers wife, puffed up. There is homosexual within the body of Christ where there is lust for debates and strife, men with men and women with women doing all sorts of sorted things that are the same as that without that we judge as being wrong. Concerning abortion Paul speaks of the Lords table and some going away drunken and others going away hungry. If we consider two feeding in the womb from the same supply of nourishment towards growth in Christ from the Lords Table: one takes all the food supply and the other gets none.

We know those things without are wrong…
I’m only suggesting do we ever examine those things within? And Deal with those before we condemn those things done in the world? But we don’t…all the focus is on those things done in the world ignoring those things done within the body.
 
Last edited:

Rockerduck

Well-Known Member
Nov 7, 2022
2,482
2,123
113
70
Marietta, Georgia.
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Personally I think everything out in the world displays a harsh truth of what ought not be going on within the body of Christ. Same with standing up against homosexuals …as vocal and disgusted as homosexuals don’t inherit the kingdom of God …still within the body of Christ there is brothers putting the bottle to their brothers mouth to get their brothers drunk and exposed so they can look on their nakedness. An example being where they were glorying in the one that had his fathers wife, puffed up. There is homosexual within the body of Christ where there lust for debates, men with men and women with women doing all sorts of sorted things that are the same as that without that we judge as wrong. Concerning abortion Paul speaks of the Lords table and some going away drunken and others going away hungry. If we consider two feeding in the womb from the same supply of nourishment towards growth in Christ from the Lords Table: one takes all the food supply and the other gets none.

We know those things without are wrong…
I’m only suggesting do we ever examine those things within? And Deal with those before we condemn those things done in the world? But we don’t…all the focus is on those things done in the world ignoring those things done within the body.
Right, Jesus said we will be persecuted, I say bring it on. I find the pastors I've talked to, are concerned about stability. They want a steady job. In the past, preachers were not interested in that, it was about saving souls. I've talked to old pastors who prayed for so many baptisms and confessions for Christ. Never mentioning money or their lifestyle. After all, a lifetime of preaching is close to 70 yrs and a few years of retirement, but forever with Christ in Heaven.
 

VictoryinJesus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2017
10,557
8,404
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Right, Jesus said we will be persecuted, I say bring it on.
What is the nature of God to allow His children to be right smack in the middle of persecution? I’ve wondered about this. I don’t think it’s so His Children will come out swinging fist, but so that they are given opportunity to overcome evil with good. So His children are made manifest in while their enemies give them bitterness to drink, they give their enemies Living water to drink. For example/ if your enemy is hungry feed him, if he is thirsty give him drink, in so doing you will pour hot coals on the enemies head and the Lord will reward you. There has to be something transformative in bringing down fire on your enemies head (so the flesh will be destroyed, but the spirit may be saved). the two models seem clear on this in how Jesus Christ when they gave Him bitterness to drink, He asked His Father to forgive them for they know not what they do. Paul (Christ in Paul) also while being blamed as a reprobate and as one who fails by the Corinthians….He said this we pray, we will be weak, that you be made strong, this we pray for your completion in Him. Then those accusing their brother as a being a fraud are urged to complete the action of loving their brothers who are “weak” and to do no wrong. Paul(Christ in Paul) openly displays he will be weak so they have opportunity to perform the action of becoming strong where (those who are strong ought to support the weak, in so doing they fulfill the Love of God).

Do we over emphasize persecution as being for self validation of being the children of God …not remembering Him who possessed all things became poor that we be made rich, even while we were yet the enemies of God? Or Him who was strong became weak, so we could be made strong and share in the inheritance of the Lord? Why will they be persecuted for My Namesake?
It’s a genuine question I have. My flesh coming out swinging, running headlong into battle to be persecuted for His namesake so I can do what I normally do which is debate, show-off and claim I’ll be a warrior for the Lords sake,
is easy. What stops me in my tracks, is the show of mercy in the face of persecution. Heels dig in to the dirt to a screeching halt and I go still, thinking giving bitterness for bitterness is easy but giving Living water for bitterness is impossible. No thank you, I want to pick a fight! I need help, Lord!? It makes more sense “deliver us from evil!” “For your Namesake!”

Personally I think claiming persecution for His Namesake is overused and slung around for everything. Most of the time I’m persecuted for doing wrong. Not for doing right. Jesus Christ was persecuted and hated for doing well and the Father being well pleased in His Son. What actions pleased the Father that He saw manifested in His Son? These are my questions…consider how often it’s “yeah bring it on! Let’s fight evil!” I remember a guy come here to post how horrible everyone was here. And he posted these long condemning messages and as soon as anyone questioned his “truth bombing” he bucked up and claimed to be being persecuted for the sake of Christ. When it also could be he came to pick a fight knowing he could rile others up,
and call it persecution for God. Everything is claimed to be being persecuted for His Namesake. Every fight picked. It’s an easy out… “I’m being persecuted for Jesus!” How do we know we are not fighting for our own namesake and calling it for His?
 
Last edited:

Wrangler

Well-Known Member
Feb 14, 2021
18,228
7,597
113
56
Shining City on a Hill
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
What is the nature of God to allow His children to be right smack in the middle of persecution? I’ve wondered about this. I don’t think it’s so His Children will come out swinging fist, but so that they are given opportunity to overcome evil with good.
I believe overcoming evil with good is God's job, not ours. Instead, I believe persecution and temptation, in general, are tests of faith.

It is easy to say "I believe in God." It becomes real when you are Daniel faced with the fire of certain death to act on your conviction. Talk is cheap. Faith is priceless.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Ritajanice

Rockerduck

Well-Known Member
Nov 7, 2022
2,482
2,123
113
70
Marietta, Georgia.
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
What is the nature of God to allow His children to be right smack in the middle of persecution? I’ve wondered about this. I don’t think it’s so His Children will come out swinging fist, but so that they are given opportunity to overcome evil with good. So His children are made manifest in while their enemies give them bitterness to drink, they give their enemies Living water to drink. For example/ if your enemy is hungry feed him, if he is thirsty give him drink, in so doing you will pour hot coals on the enemies head and the Lord will reward you. There has to be something transformative in bringing down fire on your enemies head (so the flesh will be destroyed, but the spirit may be saved). the two models seem clear on this in how Jesus Christ when they gave Him bitterness to drink, He asked His Father to forgive them for they know not what they do. Paul (Christ in Paul) also while being blamed as a reprobate and as one who fails by the Corinthians….He said this we pray, we will be weak, that you be made strong, this we pray for your completion in Him. Then those accusing their brother as a being a fraud are urged to complete the action of loving their brothers who are “weak” and to do no wrong. Paul(Christ in Paul) openly displays he will be weak so they have opportunity to perform the action of becoming strong where (those who are strong ought to support the weak, in so doing they fulfill the Love of God).

Do we over emphasize persecution as being for self validation of being the children of God …not remembering Him who possessed all things became poor that we be made rich, even while we were yet the enemies of God? Or Him who was strong became weak, so we could be made strong and share in the inheritance of the Lord? Why will they be persecuted for My Namesake?
It’s a genuine question I have. My flesh coming out swinging, running headlong into battle to be persecuted for His namesake so I can do what I normally do which is debate, show-off and claim I’ll be a warrior for the Lords sake,
is easy. What stops me in my tracks, is the show of mercy in the face of persecution. Heels dig in to the dirt to a screeching halt and I go still, thinking giving bitterness for bitterness is easy but giving Living water for bitterness is impossible. No thank you, I want to pick a fight! I need help, Lord!? It makes more sense “deliver us from evil!” “For your Namesake!”

Personally I think claiming persecution for His Namesake is overused and slung around for everything. Most of the time I’m persecuted for doing wrong. Not for doing right. Jesus Christ was persecuted and hated for doing well and the Father being well pleased in His Son. What actions pleased the Father that He saw manifested in His Son? These are my questions…consider how often it’s “yeah bring it on! Let’s fight evil!” I remember a guy come here to post how horrible everyone was here. And he posted these long condemning messages and as soon as anyone questioned his “truth bombing” he bucked up and claimed to be being persecuted for the sake of Christ. When it also could be he came to pick a fight knowing he could rile others up,
and call it persecution for God. Everything is claimed to be being persecuted for His Namesake. Every fight picked. It’s an easy out… “I’m being persecuted for Jesus!” How do we know we are not fighting for our own namesake and calling it for His?
The persecution of Christians conquered Rome and became the Holy Roman empire. Every time Christians are persecuted it conquers. Iran has the fastest and largest Christian population in the middle east. Mosques are closing and Churches are being built because of their persecution of Christians and the governments hands are tied.
 

VictoryinJesus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2017
10,557
8,404
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
The persecution of Christians conquered Rome and became the Holy Roman empire. Every time Christians are persecuted it conquers. Iran has the fastest and largest Christian population in the middle east. Mosques are closing and Churches are being built because of their persecution of Christians and the governments hands are tied.
I don’t understand all of that. To me I hear it locally and how we are to apply it in our own lives. How we handle putting on the whole armor of God. I’m not good with history. Im talking application for every day living.
 

DuckieLady

Well-Known Member
Jan 8, 2021
3,768
6,745
113
Midwest-ish
m.youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Specifically, I asked him if he believes that it's moral for a healthy woman to abort her healthy baby. His response was "It's none of my business".

All I could say was "Wow!".

What do you think about his response?
A lot of pastors have to answer according to the belief and standards of the church and not necessarily what they believe.

I'm not under that, so I would give the same answer Jesus would. Having said that, I feel like from living in a small town that people know more about how to talk about people than they do how to help them.

There is sometimes too much judgment towards people for the situations they are in, instead of just showing the gospel through love and kindness.

Do I agree with a person's actions? No, but if someone did and needed healing after, I would still be there for them. I think that's something we're missing in our culture. Isn't that what God does for us? Isn't that kind of the whole point of the cross?
 
  • Love
Reactions: VictoryinJesus

DuckieLady

Well-Known Member
Jan 8, 2021
3,768
6,745
113
Midwest-ish
m.youtube.com
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
I really feel the need to clarify what I said above.

If we could imagine meeting Jesus face to face. You know Jesus knows you and every sin you've committed. And yet, the character of Jesus is abounding in love, understanding, cares for you, is patient, and most of all peace, but he does not lie.

So imagine if we brought that same calmness, peace, compassion towards people who may not be open to the gospel yet. If there is anything that would have opened my heart up in my youth, it would have been that kind of acceptance and care.

If we could show represent the character of Christ to people in our lives and be honest without shaming, I feel like that is a better form of ministry.

It is an interesting concept. What would it be like for people to know Jesus by seeing his peace through you?
 

VictoryinJesus

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2017
10,557
8,404
113
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
A lot of pastors have to answer according to the belief and standards of the church and not necessarily what they believe.

I'm not under that, so I would give the same answer Jesus would. Having said that, I feel like from living in a small town that people know more about how to talk about people than they do how to help them.

There is sometimes too much judgment towards people for the situations they are in, instead of just showing the gospel through love and kindness.

Do I agree with a person's actions? No, but if someone did and needed healing after, I would still be there for them. I think that's something we're missing in our culture. Isn't that what God does for us? Isn't that kind of the whole point of the cross?
Agree “that people know more about how to talk about people than they do how to help them.” I love your last two paragraphs also.

Honestly topics like these make me think. I had an abortion when I was a teen. I was ignorant and without knowledge of God. I’d heard about God but looking back now, even though I thought I knew God, I had no true knowledge of God. I would never have an abortion now and if I could go back I wouldn’t have one then. It’s a reminder though, I think, same as Paul’s reminder that he consented to Stephens death. It is a reminder for me to not judge those without knowledge of God for the ignorant actions they do.

This topic makes me think back and even though others may not agree…I know God can restore the wrongs we’ve did prior to knowledge of Him. That is hopeful concerning what I did wrong prior to knowledge of God. People may say it’s hopeless but looking at the wrong Paul did to Stephen, and then how God took hold of the harm and has victory and triumph over Paul’s ignorance. where even though Stephen died at the hands of those doing wrong, that isn’t the end of the story. I hope in the same way God will restore the Life I took as a teen, and it is not the end of the story of God’s Victory over sin and the wrong done.

My point in sharing I’ve did what this thread is against …is to share there is prior to knowledge of God and the things we did, and then there is after having knowledge of God. I still think even worse now is two fold: I would NOT make that same decision now, and also I better get it through my head (and acknowledge) that abortion of new converts who are weak and without knowledge is also equally wrong. Aborting God’s little children coming to Him. …as Paul said if he hurt one of those weak and without knowledge, then he so sinned again Christ whom died for those who are weak and without knowledge. This coming from one (Saul) who consented to the stoning of Stephen. And now …Saul went from murder -to I will not harm those weak for in so doing, I harm Christ.

Significant to me is Stephen was killed.
If Paul had no Hope in God’s restoration of what Saul did wrong. Paul would have been miserable and without hope.
 
Last edited:
  • Love
Reactions: DuckieLady

Bob Estey

Well-Known Member
Aug 18, 2021
5,788
3,126
113
72
Sparks, Nevada
Faith
Christian
Country
United States
Specifically, I asked him if he believes that it's moral for a healthy woman to abort her healthy baby. His response was "It's none of my business".

All I could say was "Wow!".

What do you think about his response?
I do think it's our business, protecting unborn children. However, I think grown women have rights, too, and if a woman is pregnant because she's been raped, I don't have the right to force her to have a baby.